{
 "schema_version": "1.0",
 "id": "koala-gifts",
 "name": "Koala Gifts",
 "research_status": "researched",
 "vendor_domain": "profitkoala.com",
 "category": "E-commerce",
 "task": "E-commerce growth",
 "summary": "Shopify app by ProfitKoala for free gifts with purchase, BOGO and buy-X-get-Y offers, gift pickers, product add-ons and add-to-cart upsell pop-ups, with plans set by the store's Shopify plan rather than by orders or revenue.",
 "best_for": "Shopify stores that want free gifts with purchase, BOGO and buy-X-get-Y offers, a gift picker, product add-ons and add-to-cart upsell pop-ups for a flat monthly price, with no cap on orders or revenue",
 "skip_if": "your store is on Shopify Advanced or Plus and runs only the occasional gift offer, since the price follows your Shopify plan and starts at $49.99 there; your promotions rely on discount codes and you do not want to check how each one combines with the gift; or you expect one ProfitKoala app to cover bundles, upsells and gifts, since they are sold as separate subscriptions",
 "honest_knock": "The price follows your Shopify plan, not how much you use the app. A store on Shopify Advanced pays $49.99 a month for the same feature list a Basic store gets for $9.99, even if it runs one gift offer a quarter. The fee does not move by itself: the help centre says that if you upgrade your Shopify plan you have 14 days to upgrade in the app as well to keep your offers active. Downgrades are pro-rated; cancellations are not.\n\nThe gift mechanics have a few traps that the help centre documents itself. The gift product must carry a normal price above zero, because the app gives it away with a 100% discount; a gift priced at zero and published to the storefront can be bought without any of the offer's conditions. A gift can also flip from free to full price at checkout when the customer adds another discount code, unless that other discount is set to combine with product discounts. And a minimum-spend rule reads the price before discounts: with a $100 threshold, a $150 product with a 50% code still earns the gift at $75. The vendor's workaround is to use compare-at prices instead of discount codes.\n\nThere is a ceiling on offers, set by Shopify rather than by the plan. Shopify allows 25 automatic discounts per store, and the app packs about ten offers into each, which the help centre puts at roughly 90 to 250 offers. Disabling one Koala discount in Shopify's own discount screen can switch off several offers at once.\n\nThe critical reviews are few but specific. A US merchant wrote in March 2025, after six days, that the gift was not applied to orders correctly and that they had to refund customers. An Australian merchant disliked the long generated discount code the gift shows at checkout (February 2025). A US merchant who paid $599 a year for another ProfitKoala app objected in November 2025 to needing a separate subscription for BOGO offers, and a merchant in Ecuador noted in April 2025 that the app had been free and now costs money. The vendor's replies to all of them are the same template asking for an email. We installed it on a Shopify development store on 17 November 2026, built a free gift offer and saw the gift added to the cart in the theme preview, but the points above come from the help centre and the reviews.",
 "pricing": {
  "status": "public",
  "entry_price": "$9.99",
  "entry_price_terms": "Basic · per month for stores on Shopify's Basic plan, or $95.88 a year",
  "from_price_usd_month": null,
  "plans": [
   {
    "name": "Basic",
    "price": "$9.99/month or $95.88/year",
    "includes": "Unlimited orders and revenue, no usage limits, 14-day free trial"
   },
   {
    "name": "Shopify",
    "price": "$29.99/month or $287.88/year",
    "includes": "Unlimited orders and revenue, no usage limits, 14-day free trial"
   },
   {
    "name": "Advanced",
    "price": "$49.99/month or $479.88/year",
    "includes": "Unlimited orders and revenue, no usage limits, 14-day free trial"
   },
   {
    "name": "Shopify Plus",
    "price": "$99.99/month or $959.88/year",
    "includes": "Unlimited orders and revenue, no usage limits, 14-day free trial"
   }
  ],
  "plans_source": "summarised from pricing.notes; every plan name and amount appears verbatim in those notes",
  "notes": "(read 2026-11-17 on apps.shopify.com/upsell-koala-gift and in our own test that day; earlier: read 2026-10-03 on apps.shopify.com/upsell-koala-gift and in the vendor's billing articles at koala-gift.crisp.help) Priced on the store's Shopify plan, not on use: the four plans carry the names of Shopify's own plans and the listing gives each the same feature list. Basic is $9.99 a month or $95.88 a year, Shopify $29.99 or $287.88, Advanced $49.99 or $479.88, and Shopify Plus $99.99 or $959.88. The listing says the yearly price saves 20%; a help article dated July 2025 says up to 50%, and the listing is the page you are billed from. Every plan has a 14-day free trial and, according to the listing, is free for development stores (our own test of 17 November 2026, below, found no free plan in the app). The help centre says there are no usage limits: unlimited orders and revenue at an unchanged price. Owners of several stores can ask support for special pricing. All charges are in USD, billed through Shopify every 30 days. Developer ProfitKoala, with an address in Vilnius, Lithuania; the listing gives a launch date of 9 October 2024 and shows 383 reviews, six of them at three stars or lower. Read again on 17 November 2026: the listing is titled Koala Upsell Free Gift & BOGO, still shows the four plans and their monthly and yearly amounts unchanged, repeats “Free for development stores” on every plan card and carries 396 reviews at 5.0 (383 on our first reading). In our own test the same day on a Shopify development store (the app calls itself Koala Upsells & Gifts in the admin) the app opened on a plan screen with only Basic Monthly and Basic Annual, the price following the store's Shopify plan, and no free plan to pick. Basic Monthly showed $19.99 struck through next to $9.99 a month, with a “Save up to 50%” badge and a 14 day free trial; Basic Annual showed $19.99 struck through next to $7.99 a month billed yearly, which is the listing's $95.88 a year, with a “Save up to 60%” badge. The struck through $19.99 is not on the listing. Shopify's approval screen for Basic Monthly read $9.99 every 30 days after a 14 day trial ending 1 December, with a $10.00 discount line and the words “You will not be billed for this test charge”; it also showed an Add payment method row, which we left empty, and Approve worked without a card. So on a development store “free for development stores” meant approving a Shopify test charge that is not billed, not a free tier inside the app.",
  "verified_at": "2026-11-17",
  "source_url": "https://apps.shopify.com/upsell-koala-gift",
  "schema_offer": {
   "price": 9.99,
   "currency": "USD",
   "description": "Basic, per month for stores on Shopify's Basic plan, or $95.88 a year; Shopify $29.99, Advanced $49.99, Shopify Plus $99.99; same features on every plan; no usage limits; 14-day free trial; free for development stores on the listing, though the app asked us to approve a plan on a development store; billed through Shopify every 30 days. Read on the vendor's own pricing page on 2026-11-17.",
   "page": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html"
  },
  "source_quotes": null,
  "recent_change": null,
  "price_history": null
 },
 "free_plan": false,
 "free_plan_evidence": null,
 "cost_traps": [
  {
   "id": "addons_extra",
   "label": "Key features are paid add-ons",
   "evidence": "A US merchant who paid $599 a year for another ProfitKoala app objected in November 2025 to needing a separate subscription for BOGO offers, and a merchant in Ecuador noted in April 2025 that the app had been free and now costs money.",
   "verified_at": "2026-11-17",
   "source_url": "https://apps.shopify.com/upsell-koala-gift"
  }
 ],
 "compare_with": {
  "name": "Koala Bundles",
  "why": "Koala Bundles comes from the same developer and is the closest comparison in our own dossiers, and the listing says the two work together. They are priced on different things. Koala Bundles, read on 30 September 2026, is metered on the bundle revenue its offers bring in: $12.99 a month up to $1,000, $19.99 up to $5,000 and $59.99 with no ceiling. Koala Gifts, read on 3 October 2026, ignores revenue and charges by the store's Shopify plan: $9.99 on Basic, $29.99 on Shopify, $49.99 on Advanced and $99.99 on Plus. A small store on Shopify's Basic plan pays less for gifts than for bundles; a large store on Advanced pays $49.99 for gifts whatever they sell, which is cheaper than Unlimited bundles. Pick Koala Bundles for quantity breaks and multi-product bundles, Koala Gifts for gift-with-purchase, BOGO and buy-X-get-Y offers."
 },
 "links": {
  "record": "https://aibuildermarketplace.com/api/v1/products/koala-gifts.json",
  "review": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html",
  "marketplace": "https://aibuildermarketplace.com/marketplace/koala-gifts/",
  "vendor_site": "https://profitkoala.com"
 },
 "purchase": {
  "seller": "the vendor",
  "how": "AIBuilder Marketplace does not sell this software. Sign up, start a trial or buy on the vendor's site.",
  "handoff_url": "https://platform.shoffi.app/r/rl_XtSfm3S9",
  "affiliate": true,
  "disclosure": "Where purchase.affiliate is true, purchase.handoff_url is an affiliate link: AIBuilder Marketplace may earn a commission at no extra cost to the buyer. Commission never changes what a record says, and products are not ranked by commission. Where it is false the link is the vendor's plain site."
 },
 "provenance": {
  "research": "hand-researched dossier, read on the vendor's own pages",
  "researched_since": "2026-07",
  "method": "https://aibuildermarketplace.com/how-we-review/",
  "license": "CC BY 4.0. Credit 'AIBuilder Marketplace' with a link to https://aibuildermarketplace.com/atlas/.",
  "note": "A rebuild is not a new measurement: pricing.verified_at is the date that matters."
 },
 "cost": {
  "status": "available",
  "engine": "https://aibuildermarketplace.com/agents/#cost",
  "rules": {
   "currency": "USD",
   "unit": "store",
   "axis": "stores",
   "plans": [
    {
     "id": "basic",
     "name": "Basic",
     "model": "per_unit",
     "monthly": 9.99,
     "annual_year": 95.88,
     "evidence": "Basic is $9.99 a month or $95.88 a year"
    },
    {
     "id": "shopify",
     "name": "Shopify",
     "model": "per_unit",
     "monthly": 29.99,
     "annual_year": 287.88,
     "evidence": "Shopify $29.99 or $287.88"
    },
    {
     "id": "advanced",
     "name": "Advanced",
     "model": "per_unit",
     "monthly": 49.99,
     "annual_year": 479.88,
     "evidence": "Advanced $49.99 or $479.88"
    },
    {
     "id": "shopify-plus",
     "name": "Shopify Plus",
     "model": "per_unit",
     "monthly": 99.99,
     "annual_year": 959.88,
     "evidence": "Shopify Plus $99.99 or $959.88"
    }
   ],
   "notes": [
    "The plan is set by the store's own Shopify plan, not chosen by usage: the four plans carry the names of Shopify's plans and the same feature list.",
    "No usage limits per the help centre: unlimited orders and revenue at an unchanged price. Billed in USD through Shopify every 30 days."
   ],
   "not_computable": [
    "Special pricing for owners of several stores is on request from support; the rules price each store at the list rate."
   ],
   "rules_verified_at": "2026-11-17"
  },
  "growth": {
   "annual": {
    "product_id": "koala-gifts",
    "currency": "USD",
    "axis": "stores",
    "unit": "store",
    "billing": "annual",
    "rows": [
     {
      "units": 1,
      "cheapest_plan": "basic",
      "cheapest_plan_name": "Basic",
      "total_month": 7.99,
      "billed": {
       "amount": 95.88,
       "every": "year"
      },
      "ranges": [],
      "per_plan": {
       "basic": 7.99,
       "shopify": 23.99,
       "advanced": 39.99,
       "shopify-plus": 79.99
      }
     },
     {
      "units": 2,
      "cheapest_plan": "basic",
      "cheapest_plan_name": "Basic",
      "total_month": 15.98,
      "billed": {
       "amount": 191.76,
       "every": "year"
      },
      "ranges": [],
      "per_plan": {
       "basic": 15.98,
       "shopify": 47.98,
       "advanced": 79.98,
       "shopify-plus": 159.98
      }
     },
     {
      "units": 3,
      "cheapest_plan": "basic",
      "cheapest_plan_name": "Basic",
      "total_month": 23.97,
      "billed": {
       "amount": 287.64,
       "every": "year"
      },
      "ranges": [],
      "per_plan": {
       "basic": 23.97,
       "shopify": 71.97,
       "advanced": 119.97,
       "shopify-plus": 239.97
      }
     },
     {
      "units": 5,
      "cheapest_plan": "basic",
      "cheapest_plan_name": "Basic",
      "total_month": 39.95,
      "billed": {
       "amount": 479.4,
       "every": "year"
      },
      "ranges": [],
      "per_plan": {
       "basic": 39.95,
       "shopify": 119.95,
       "advanced": 199.95,
       "shopify-plus": 399.95
      }
     },
     {
      "units": 10,
      "cheapest_plan": "basic",
      "cheapest_plan_name": "Basic",
      "total_month": 79.9,
      "billed": {
       "amount": 958.8,
       "every": "year"
      },
      "ranges": [],
      "per_plan": {
       "basic": 79.9,
       "shopify": 239.9,
       "advanced": 399.9,
       "shopify-plus": 799.9
      }
     }
    ],
    "switch_points": [],
    "conflicts": [],
    "unknowns": [
     "Special pricing for owners of several stores is on request from support; the rules price each store at the list rate."
    ],
    "measured": [
     {
      "claim": "free for development stores",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "The app did not open without a plan: the first screen was Choose your plan with only Basic Monthly and Basic Annual, no free plan, and a Basic Monthly test charge had to be approved before the Create a Gift Offer flow opened. No card was needed and nothing was billed.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Basic Monthly test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
      "comparability": "The dossier wording against the first screen and the approval screen on one development store.",
      "status": "contradicted",
      "buying_consequence": "The app is not free for a development store in the sense that a plan and a test charge are needed first; no card was needed.",
      "buyer_direction": "unfavourable",
      "claim_changed_on": null,
      "status_label": "Contradicted",
      "review_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html"
     },
     {
      "claim": "Great job - your offer is live!",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "Right after saving, the same screen showed the status Not visible, the warning that the app needs activation in the theme settings and the card Great job - your offer is live!. The offer only showed in the cart after the app embed was switched on in the theme editor.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Basic Monthly test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
      "comparability": "Card text versus the status badge and warning on the same app screen and the cart in the theme preview.",
      "status": "contradicted",
      "buying_consequence": "A new offer is not visible to shoppers until the theme embed is switched on, although the card says it is live.",
      "buyer_direction": "unfavourable",
      "claim_changed_on": null,
      "status_label": "Contradicted",
      "review_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html"
     },
     {
      "claim": "Basic, $9.99 a month, 14-day free trial",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "The Choose your plan screen shows Basic Monthly at $9.99 a month with $19.99 struck through and Start 14-day free trial. The Shopify approval screen showed $19,99 struck through and $9,99 USD every 30 days with a label $10,00 off all charges, a 14-day free trial ending on 1 Dec. and Total $9,99 Due 1 Dec plus any applicable taxes. How long the $10 discount lasts was not shown.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Basic Monthly test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
      "comparability": "The dossier price against the plan card and the approval screen; the length of the discount and the taxes were not shown.",
      "status": "confirmed",
      "buying_consequence": "Basic costs $9.99 a month after a 14-day trial, but the list price shown is $19.99 and it is not shown how long the $10 discount runs.",
      "buyer_direction": "neutral",
      "claim_changed_on": null,
      "status_label": "Confirmed",
      "review_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html"
     }
    ]
   },
   "monthly": {
    "product_id": "koala-gifts",
    "currency": "USD",
    "axis": "stores",
    "unit": "store",
    "billing": "monthly",
    "rows": [
     {
      "units": 1,
      "cheapest_plan": "basic",
      "cheapest_plan_name": "Basic",
      "total_month": 9.99,
      "billed": {
       "amount": 9.99,
       "every": "month"
      },
      "ranges": [],
      "per_plan": {
       "basic": 9.99,
       "shopify": 29.99,
       "advanced": 49.99,
       "shopify-plus": 99.99
      }
     },
     {
      "units": 2,
      "cheapest_plan": "basic",
      "cheapest_plan_name": "Basic",
      "total_month": 19.98,
      "billed": {
       "amount": 19.98,
       "every": "month"
      },
      "ranges": [],
      "per_plan": {
       "basic": 19.98,
       "shopify": 59.98,
       "advanced": 99.98,
       "shopify-plus": 199.98
      }
     },
     {
      "units": 3,
      "cheapest_plan": "basic",
      "cheapest_plan_name": "Basic",
      "total_month": 29.97,
      "billed": {
       "amount": 29.97,
       "every": "month"
      },
      "ranges": [],
      "per_plan": {
       "basic": 29.97,
       "shopify": 89.97,
       "advanced": 149.97,
       "shopify-plus": 299.97
      }
     },
     {
      "units": 5,
      "cheapest_plan": "basic",
      "cheapest_plan_name": "Basic",
      "total_month": 49.95,
      "billed": {
       "amount": 49.95,
       "every": "month"
      },
      "ranges": [],
      "per_plan": {
       "basic": 49.95,
       "shopify": 149.95,
       "advanced": 249.95,
       "shopify-plus": 499.95
      }
     },
     {
      "units": 10,
      "cheapest_plan": "basic",
      "cheapest_plan_name": "Basic",
      "total_month": 99.9,
      "billed": {
       "amount": 99.9,
       "every": "month"
      },
      "ranges": [],
      "per_plan": {
       "basic": 99.9,
       "shopify": 299.9,
       "advanced": 499.9,
       "shopify-plus": 999.9
      }
     }
    ],
    "switch_points": [],
    "conflicts": [],
    "unknowns": [
     "Special pricing for owners of several stores is on request from support; the rules price each store at the list rate."
    ],
    "measured": [
     {
      "claim": "free for development stores",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "The app did not open without a plan: the first screen was Choose your plan with only Basic Monthly and Basic Annual, no free plan, and a Basic Monthly test charge had to be approved before the Create a Gift Offer flow opened. No card was needed and nothing was billed.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Basic Monthly test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
      "comparability": "The dossier wording against the first screen and the approval screen on one development store.",
      "status": "contradicted",
      "buying_consequence": "The app is not free for a development store in the sense that a plan and a test charge are needed first; no card was needed.",
      "buyer_direction": "unfavourable",
      "claim_changed_on": null,
      "status_label": "Contradicted",
      "review_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html"
     },
     {
      "claim": "Great job - your offer is live!",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "Right after saving, the same screen showed the status Not visible, the warning that the app needs activation in the theme settings and the card Great job - your offer is live!. The offer only showed in the cart after the app embed was switched on in the theme editor.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Basic Monthly test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
      "comparability": "Card text versus the status badge and warning on the same app screen and the cart in the theme preview.",
      "status": "contradicted",
      "buying_consequence": "A new offer is not visible to shoppers until the theme embed is switched on, although the card says it is live.",
      "buyer_direction": "unfavourable",
      "claim_changed_on": null,
      "status_label": "Contradicted",
      "review_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html"
     },
     {
      "claim": "Basic, $9.99 a month, 14-day free trial",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "The Choose your plan screen shows Basic Monthly at $9.99 a month with $19.99 struck through and Start 14-day free trial. The Shopify approval screen showed $19,99 struck through and $9,99 USD every 30 days with a label $10,00 off all charges, a 14-day free trial ending on 1 Dec. and Total $9,99 Due 1 Dec plus any applicable taxes. How long the $10 discount lasts was not shown.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Basic Monthly test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
      "comparability": "The dossier price against the plan card and the approval screen; the length of the discount and the taxes were not shown.",
      "status": "confirmed",
      "buying_consequence": "Basic costs $9.99 a month after a 14-day trial, but the list price shown is $19.99 and it is not shown how long the $10 discount runs.",
      "buyer_direction": "neutral",
      "claim_changed_on": null,
      "status_label": "Confirmed",
      "review_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html"
     }
    ]
   }
  }
 },
 "unknowns": [
  "Data export tested on 2026-11-17; contract terms not researched. Scope and untested export routes are listed in measured.exit_test.",
  "Being verified: refund terms are not yet matched to a verbatim line on the vendor's own pages. Not matched does not mean there is none."
 ],
 "verification": {
  "price": "read",
  "free_trial": "measured",
  "refund": "being_verified"
 },
 "status_page": null,
 "measured": {
  "support": null,
  "onboarding": null,
  "inbox": null,
  "invites": null,
  "entry_exit": {
   "signup": {
    "screens": "not_tested",
    "card_required": "not_tested",
    "call_required": "not_tested",
    "observed_on": null,
    "evidence_url": null
   },
   "cancel": {
    "screens": "not_tested",
    "call_required": "not_tested",
    "observed_on": null,
    "evidence_url": null
   }
  },
  "tested_on": "2026-11-17",
  "tested_by": "Our team; actor, account and scope are documented in the review.",
  "review_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html",
  "method": [
   "The app was installed on our Shopify development store, which Daan set up, and our AI assistant ran the test in Daan's browser",
   "Evidence screenshots are in English with names and addresses masked"
  ],
  "claims": [
   {
    "claim": "Basic, $9.99 a month, 14-day free trial",
    "claim_source": "our test notes",
    "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
    "observed": "The Choose your plan screen shows Basic Monthly at $9.99 a month with $19.99 struck through and Start 14-day free trial. The Shopify approval screen showed $19,99 struck through and $9,99 USD every 30 days with a label $10,00 off all charges, a 14-day free trial ending on 1 Dec. and Total $9,99 Due 1 Dec plus any applicable taxes. How long the $10 discount lasts was not shown.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence": {
     "label": "Our test observations",
     "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
    },
    "plan": "Basic Monthly test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
    "comparability": "The dossier price against the plan card and the approval screen; the length of the discount and the taxes were not shown.",
    "status": "confirmed",
    "buying_consequence": "Basic costs $9.99 a month after a 14-day trial, but the list price shown is $19.99 and it is not shown how long the $10 discount runs.",
    "buyer_direction": "neutral",
    "claim_changed_on": null
   },
   {
    "claim": "$95.88 a year",
    "claim_source": "our test notes",
    "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
    "observed": "The Basic Annual card shows $7.99 a month, Billed yearly, with $19.99 struck through. Twelve times $7.99 is $95.88, so the dossier figure follows from the card; the annual approval screen was not opened, so no yearly total was seen on a screen.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence": {
     "label": "Our test observations",
     "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
    },
    "plan": "Basic Monthly test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
    "comparability": "The dossier yearly price against a calculation from the Basic Annual card; no yearly approval screen was seen.",
    "status": "confirmed",
    "buying_consequence": "The yearly plan comes to $95.88 a year by calculation; no yearly total was seen on a screen.",
    "buyer_direction": "neutral",
    "claim_changed_on": null
   },
   {
    "claim": "free for development stores",
    "claim_source": "our test notes",
    "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
    "observed": "The app did not open without a plan: the first screen was Choose your plan with only Basic Monthly and Basic Annual, no free plan, and a Basic Monthly test charge had to be approved before the Create a Gift Offer flow opened. No card was needed and nothing was billed.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence": {
     "label": "Our test observations",
     "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
    },
    "plan": "Basic Monthly test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
    "comparability": "The dossier wording against the first screen and the approval screen on one development store.",
    "status": "contradicted",
    "buying_consequence": "The app is not free for a development store in the sense that a plan and a test charge are needed first; no card was needed.",
    "buyer_direction": "unfavourable",
    "claim_changed_on": null
   },
   {
    "claim": "Add a gift to customer's cart automatically",
    "claim_source": "our test notes",
    "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
    "observed": "The exposure Add a gift to customer's cart automatically was chosen, the trigger was Specific Product Demo Mug and the gift Demo Shirt at Free; Save gave Offer created successfully!. With the app embed switched on in an unsaved theme preview, adding Demo Mug put Demo Shirt $19.00 $0.00 FREE GIFT in the cart, about 3 minutes and 9 steps after the install. The theme was not saved, no widget was seen on the product page and the checkout was not opened.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence": {
     "label": "Our test observations",
     "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
    },
    "plan": "Basic Monthly test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
    "comparability": "The claim that the gift is added automatically against the cart drawer of an unsaved theme preview; the checkout and the live store were not seen.",
    "status": "confirmed",
    "buying_consequence": "A free gift can be added to the cart automatically in a few minutes; it was seen in the cart of a preview and not in the checkout.",
    "buyer_direction": "neutral",
    "claim_changed_on": null
   },
   {
    "claim": "Great job - your offer is live!",
    "claim_source": "our test notes",
    "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
    "observed": "Right after saving, the same screen showed the status Not visible, the warning that the app needs activation in the theme settings and the card Great job - your offer is live!. The offer only showed in the cart after the app embed was switched on in the theme editor.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence": {
     "label": "Our test observations",
     "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
    },
    "plan": "Basic Monthly test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
    "comparability": "Card text versus the status badge and warning on the same app screen and the cart in the theme preview.",
    "status": "contradicted",
    "buying_consequence": "A new offer is not visible to shoppers until the theme embed is switched on, although the card says it is live.",
    "buyer_direction": "unfavourable",
    "claim_changed_on": null
   },
   {
    "claim": "$19,99 $9,99 USD every 30 days",
    "claim_source": "our test notes",
    "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
    "observed": "The plan card showed Basic Monthly at $9.99 a month with $19.99 struck through. The Shopify approval screen said $19,99 struck through and $9,99 USD every 30 days, Subtotal $19,99, Discount $10,00 off, Total $9,99 Due 1 Dec plus any applicable taxes, and was approved as a test charge without a card. Card and approval screen agree; tax is unknown.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence": {
     "label": "Our test observations",
     "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
    },
    "plan": "Basic Monthly test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
    "comparability": "The plan card against the Shopify approval screen for the same plan; the same amount, no tax line was shown and no stored cost rule was compared.",
    "status": "confirmed",
    "buying_consequence": "The first bill of $9.99 is due on 1 Dec after the trial, before taxes; the list price is $19.99.",
    "buyer_direction": "neutral",
    "claim_changed_on": null
   }
  ],
  "exit_test": {
   "run_date": "2026-11-17",
   "what": "Daan created the account and our AI assistant ran the test in Daan's browser. On 17 November 2026 the session tested Koala Upsells & Gifts (listed as Koala Upsell Free Gift & BOGO) on a Shopify development store: the install through the install form, the plan wall (no free plan), the Basic Monthly test charge (approved without a card, billed 0 dollars), one free gift offer (Demo Shirt for Demo Mug) that stood in the cart as Demo Shirt $19.00 $0.00 FREE GIFT in an unsaved theme preview about 3 minutes and 9 steps after the install, the contradiction on the offer screen (Not visible, activation needed and Great job - your offer is live!), and the uninstall with a required reason. The gift picker, upsells, the Advanced and Plus plans and the real checkout were not tested. Nothing was paid. Install: the App Store listing is apps.shopify.com/upsell-koala-gift, titled Koala Upsell Free Gift & BOGO, by ProfitKoala, with From $9.99/month. Free trial available. and a rating of 5.0 from 396 reviews; the address apps.shopify.com/koala-gifts does not exist. In the Shopify admin the app is called Koala Upsells & Gifts. The app was installed through the install form with the target set to the same tab, in our own tab, at 21:38. The screen Install app said that the app needs access to View customer data, View staff and contributor data and View and edit store data (Products, orders, discounts, Online Store); Install was clicked. There was no separate account or password: the app opened at once on Choose your plan. Plan wall: there is no free plan and nothing could be built before a plan was chosen. The plan was activated at 21:39 after the Shopify approval screen (see Checkout); the dashboard then said Plan activated successfully!, with Theme status 0/3 app blocks added to theme and a Setup guide at 0 / 4 steps completed. Core action, a free gift added automatically: Create a Gift Offer, then Select gift offer exposure with four options, of which Add a gift to customer's cart automatically was chosen, then New gift offer with the default name Buy One Product to get a Free Gift!. The trigger was Specific Product, Demo Mug ($9.50), and the reward was Demo Shirt ($19.00) at Free. Save gave Offer created successfully!. Visibility: right after saving, the same screen showed the status Not visible, the warning Koala Upsells & Gifts app needs activation in theme settings with Your offers aren't available on your product page, and at the same time a card saying Great job - your offer is live!. These contradict each other: the offer is only visible once the app embed is switched on in the theme. In the theme editor (preview with the app embeds) the embed Koala Gifts was switched on and NOT saved. In the unsaved preview, adding Demo Mug to the cart gave a cart with Demo Shirt $19.00 $0.00 FREE GIFT and Demo Mug $9.50. The editor was left with Leave page, so nothing was saved. No gift widget was seen on the product page itself, only in the cart. From the install at 21:38 to the free gift in the cart at 21:41 took about 3 minutes and about 9 steps (choose and approve the plan, choose the offer type, trigger, gift, save, switch on the embed, open the product, add to cart). The checkout of the store was not opened. Plans in the app (Choose your plan, with the line The price for your plan will be based on your Shopify plan): Basic Monthly, $19.99 struck through and $9.99 a month, Start 14-day free trial, with the badge Save up to 50%; Basic Annual, $19.99 struck through and $7.99 a month, Billed yearly, with the badges Save up to 60% and Priority support. Both say You won't be charged before your trial ends. Cancel anytime. The features listed are pop-up upsells on add to cart click, product add-ons and gift banners, gifts added to the cart automatically, rules by customer location and historical purchases, block designs, unlimited gifted products and upsell revenue, and live chat. The Advanced and Plus prices were not seen because the development store is on Basic. Checkout: Start 14-day free trial on Basic Monthly opened the Shopify screen Approve subscription with the notice You will not be billed for this test charge., Basic Monthly, $19,99 struck through and $9,99 USD every 30 days, a label $10,00 off all charges, You have a 14-day free trial ending on 1 Dec., Subtotal $19,99 plus any applicable taxes, Discount $10,00 off, Total $9,99 Due 1 Dec, and a row Add payment method that did not have to be filled in. Approve worked without a card and was clicked: a test charge was approved, no card was entered and no payment method was added, and nothing was billed. The Basic Annual screen was not opened. Cancelling: the route in the app was not looked for. In Shopify, Settings, Apps, the menu next to the app has Uninstall; its dialog says You'll no longer be able to use the app, that data managed by the app, such as discounts, will be deleted, and that a request goes to the developer within 48 hours to delete all personal customer information. A reason for uninstalling is required (Testing multiple apps was chosen). The app was uninstalled at 21:44 (You've successfully uninstalled Koala Upsells & Gifts) and the subscription lapses with it. Differences from the review: the listing and the dossier say the app is free for development stores, but the app asked for a plan and a test charge before anything could be built. The strikethrough $19.99 on both plans is not in the dossier, and the annual plan is shown as $7.99 a month billed yearly, which makes $95.88 a year. The price fields are not changed here. Not tested: the gift picker (Give customers a choice of products), gift banners, upsells, the Koala Bundles tab, Kopa AI, the Advanced and Plus plans, the real checkout, analytics and live chat. Clean up: the embed was not saved. The offer and the plan went with the uninstall. Our own tab was closed. No kit records were entered.",
   "first_import": null,
   "file_inspected": false,
   "reimport_tested": false,
   "awkward": "The app does not open without a plan, although the dossier says it is free for development stores. After saving, the offer screen showed Not visible, a warning that the app needs activation in the theme settings and Great job - your offer is live! at the same time. The gift only showed in the cart, not as a widget on the product page. Uninstalling needs a reason to be chosen.",
   "friction": {
    "export_route": "No export or reimport was performed; no file was downloaded or examined. The two categorised kit records were not entered; the objects tested were not kit records.",
    "format": "No downloaded bytes examined.",
    "reimport": "No reimport performed.",
    "cancellation": "No cancellation or downgrade performed."
   },
   "not_tested": [
    "Original store creation and identity check, which Daan did himself.",
    "The gift picker, gift banners and upsells.",
    "The Koala Bundles tab, Kopa AI, analytics and live chat.",
    "The Advanced and Plus plans and the Basic Annual approval screen.",
    "The checkout of the store and the live store.",
    "Export and reimport.",
    "Session and source-reading date: 17 November 2026. Times are CET. The session started at about 21:38 CET. These are approximate tester observations, not benchmark timings. Midnight timestamps are required date anchors, not measured event times."
   ],
   "available_fields": [],
   "not_offered": [],
   "note": "A check of this export route with synthetic records, on the account and date stated. Re-importing the export was not tested. The exported file was not opened, so what it contains is unverified. Friction is described, not scored; this is not a verdict on the product.",
   "evidence_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#exit-test"
  },
  "facts": {
   "trial_requires_card": {
    "value": "not_tested",
    "basis": "No explicit observation in the public evidence.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#hands-on"
   },
   "trial_duration_confirmed": {
    "value": true,
    "basis": "The Choose your plan screen shows Basic Monthly at $9.99 a month with $19.99 struck through and Start 14-day free trial. The Shopify approval screen showed $19,99 struck through and $9,99 USD every 30 days with a label $10,00 off all charges, a 14-day free trial ending on 1 Dec. and Total $9,99 Due 1 Dec plus any applicable taxes. How long the $10 discount lasts was not shown.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
   },
   "export_file_inspected": {
    "value": false,
    "basis": "Daan created the account and our AI assistant ran the test in Daan's browser. On 17 November 2026 the session tested Koala Upsells & Gifts (listed as Koala Upsell Free Gift & BOGO) on a Shopify development store: the install through the install form, the plan wall (no free plan), the Basic Monthly test charge (approved without a card, billed 0 dollars), one free gift offer (Demo Shirt for Demo Mug) that stood in the cart as Demo Shirt $19.00 $0.00 FREE GIFT in an unsaved theme preview about 3 minutes and 9 steps after the install, the contradiction on the offer screen (Not visible, activation needed and Great job - your offer is live!), and the uninstall with a required reason. The gift picker, upsells, the Advanced and Plus plans and the real checkout were not tested. Nothing was paid. Install: the App Store listing is apps.shopify.com/upsell-koala-gift, titled Koala Upsell Free Gift & BOGO, by ProfitKoala, with From $9.99/month. Free trial available. and a rating of 5.0 from 396 reviews; the address apps.shopify.com/koala-gifts does not exist. In the Shopify admin the app is called Koala Upsells & Gifts. The app was installed through the install form with the target set to the same tab, in our own tab, at 21:38. The screen Install app said that the app needs access to View customer data, View staff and contributor data and View and edit store data (Products, orders, discounts, Online Store); Install was clicked. There was no separate account or password: the app opened at once on Choose your plan. Plan wall: there is no free plan and nothing could be built before a plan was chosen. The plan was activated at 21:39 after the Shopify approval screen (see Checkout); the dashboard then said Plan activated successfully!, with Theme status 0/3 app blocks added to theme and a Setup guide at 0 / 4 steps completed. Core action, a free gift added automatically: Create a Gift Offer, then Select gift offer exposure with four options, of which Add a gift to customer's cart automatically was chosen, then New gift offer with the default name Buy One Product to get a Free Gift!. The trigger was Specific Product, Demo Mug ($9.50), and the reward was Demo Shirt ($19.00) at Free. Save gave Offer created successfully!. Visibility: right after saving, the same screen showed the status Not visible, the warning Koala Upsells & Gifts app needs activation in theme settings with Your offers aren't available on your product page, and at the same time a card saying Great job - your offer is live!. These contradict each other: the offer is only visible once the app embed is switched on in the theme. In the theme editor (preview with the app embeds) the embed Koala Gifts was switched on and NOT saved. In the unsaved preview, adding Demo Mug to the cart gave a cart with Demo Shirt $19.00 $0.00 FREE GIFT and Demo Mug $9.50. The editor was left with Leave page, so nothing was saved. No gift widget was seen on the product page itself, only in the cart. From the install at 21:38 to the free gift in the cart at 21:41 took about 3 minutes and about 9 steps (choose and approve the plan, choose the offer type, trigger, gift, save, switch on the embed, open the product, add to cart). The checkout of the store was not opened. Plans in the app (Choose your plan, with the line The price for your plan will be based on your Shopify plan): Basic Monthly, $19.99 struck through and $9.99 a month, Start 14-day free trial, with the badge Save up to 50%; Basic Annual, $19.99 struck through and $7.99 a month, Billed yearly, with the badges Save up to 60% and Priority support. Both say You won't be charged before your trial ends. Cancel anytime. The features listed are pop-up upsells on add to cart click, product add-ons and gift banners, gifts added to the cart automatically, rules by customer location and historical purchases, block designs, unlimited gifted products and upsell revenue, and live chat. The Advanced and Plus prices were not seen because the development store is on Basic. Checkout: Start 14-day free trial on Basic Monthly opened the Shopify screen Approve subscription with the notice You will not be billed for this test charge., Basic Monthly, $19,99 struck through and $9,99 USD every 30 days, a label $10,00 off all charges, You have a 14-day free trial ending on 1 Dec., Subtotal $19,99 plus any applicable taxes, Discount $10,00 off, Total $9,99 Due 1 Dec, and a row Add payment method that did not have to be filled in. Approve worked without a card and was clicked: a test charge was approved, no card was entered and no payment method was added, and nothing was billed. The Basic Annual screen was not opened. Cancelling: the route in the app was not looked for. In Shopify, Settings, Apps, the menu next to the app has Uninstall; its dialog says You'll no longer be able to use the app, that data managed by the app, such as discounts, will be deleted, and that a request goes to the developer within 48 hours to delete all personal customer information. A reason for uninstalling is required (Testing multiple apps was chosen). The app was uninstalled at 21:44 (You've successfully uninstalled Koala Upsells & Gifts) and the subscription lapses with it. Differences from the review: the listing and the dossier say the app is free for development stores, but the app asked for a plan and a test charge before anything could be built. The strikethrough $19.99 on both plans is not in the dossier, and the annual plan is shown as $7.99 a month billed yearly, which makes $95.88 a year. The price fields are not changed here. Not tested: the gift picker (Give customers a choice of products), gift banners, upsells, the Koala Bundles tab, Kopa AI, the Advanced and Plus plans, the real checkout, analytics and live chat. Clean up: the embed was not saved. The offer and the plan went with the uninstall. Our own tab was closed. No kit records were entered. A check of this export route with synthetic records, on the account and date stated. Re-importing the export was not tested. The exported file was not opened, so what it contains is unverified. Friction is described, not scored; this is not a verdict on the product.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#exit-test"
   },
   "export_reimport_tested": {
    "value": false,
    "basis": "Daan created the account and our AI assistant ran the test in Daan's browser. On 17 November 2026 the session tested Koala Upsells & Gifts (listed as Koala Upsell Free Gift & BOGO) on a Shopify development store: the install through the install form, the plan wall (no free plan), the Basic Monthly test charge (approved without a card, billed 0 dollars), one free gift offer (Demo Shirt for Demo Mug) that stood in the cart as Demo Shirt $19.00 $0.00 FREE GIFT in an unsaved theme preview about 3 minutes and 9 steps after the install, the contradiction on the offer screen (Not visible, activation needed and Great job - your offer is live!), and the uninstall with a required reason. The gift picker, upsells, the Advanced and Plus plans and the real checkout were not tested. Nothing was paid. Install: the App Store listing is apps.shopify.com/upsell-koala-gift, titled Koala Upsell Free Gift & BOGO, by ProfitKoala, with From $9.99/month. Free trial available. and a rating of 5.0 from 396 reviews; the address apps.shopify.com/koala-gifts does not exist. In the Shopify admin the app is called Koala Upsells & Gifts. The app was installed through the install form with the target set to the same tab, in our own tab, at 21:38. The screen Install app said that the app needs access to View customer data, View staff and contributor data and View and edit store data (Products, orders, discounts, Online Store); Install was clicked. There was no separate account or password: the app opened at once on Choose your plan. Plan wall: there is no free plan and nothing could be built before a plan was chosen. The plan was activated at 21:39 after the Shopify approval screen (see Checkout); the dashboard then said Plan activated successfully!, with Theme status 0/3 app blocks added to theme and a Setup guide at 0 / 4 steps completed. Core action, a free gift added automatically: Create a Gift Offer, then Select gift offer exposure with four options, of which Add a gift to customer's cart automatically was chosen, then New gift offer with the default name Buy One Product to get a Free Gift!. The trigger was Specific Product, Demo Mug ($9.50), and the reward was Demo Shirt ($19.00) at Free. Save gave Offer created successfully!. Visibility: right after saving, the same screen showed the status Not visible, the warning Koala Upsells & Gifts app needs activation in theme settings with Your offers aren't available on your product page, and at the same time a card saying Great job - your offer is live!. These contradict each other: the offer is only visible once the app embed is switched on in the theme. In the theme editor (preview with the app embeds) the embed Koala Gifts was switched on and NOT saved. In the unsaved preview, adding Demo Mug to the cart gave a cart with Demo Shirt $19.00 $0.00 FREE GIFT and Demo Mug $9.50. The editor was left with Leave page, so nothing was saved. No gift widget was seen on the product page itself, only in the cart. From the install at 21:38 to the free gift in the cart at 21:41 took about 3 minutes and about 9 steps (choose and approve the plan, choose the offer type, trigger, gift, save, switch on the embed, open the product, add to cart). The checkout of the store was not opened. Plans in the app (Choose your plan, with the line The price for your plan will be based on your Shopify plan): Basic Monthly, $19.99 struck through and $9.99 a month, Start 14-day free trial, with the badge Save up to 50%; Basic Annual, $19.99 struck through and $7.99 a month, Billed yearly, with the badges Save up to 60% and Priority support. Both say You won't be charged before your trial ends. Cancel anytime. The features listed are pop-up upsells on add to cart click, product add-ons and gift banners, gifts added to the cart automatically, rules by customer location and historical purchases, block designs, unlimited gifted products and upsell revenue, and live chat. The Advanced and Plus prices were not seen because the development store is on Basic. Checkout: Start 14-day free trial on Basic Monthly opened the Shopify screen Approve subscription with the notice You will not be billed for this test charge., Basic Monthly, $19,99 struck through and $9,99 USD every 30 days, a label $10,00 off all charges, You have a 14-day free trial ending on 1 Dec., Subtotal $19,99 plus any applicable taxes, Discount $10,00 off, Total $9,99 Due 1 Dec, and a row Add payment method that did not have to be filled in. Approve worked without a card and was clicked: a test charge was approved, no card was entered and no payment method was added, and nothing was billed. The Basic Annual screen was not opened. Cancelling: the route in the app was not looked for. In Shopify, Settings, Apps, the menu next to the app has Uninstall; its dialog says You'll no longer be able to use the app, that data managed by the app, such as discounts, will be deleted, and that a request goes to the developer within 48 hours to delete all personal customer information. A reason for uninstalling is required (Testing multiple apps was chosen). The app was uninstalled at 21:44 (You've successfully uninstalled Koala Upsells & Gifts) and the subscription lapses with it. Differences from the review: the listing and the dossier say the app is free for development stores, but the app asked for a plan and a test charge before anything could be built. The strikethrough $19.99 on both plans is not in the dossier, and the annual plan is shown as $7.99 a month billed yearly, which makes $95.88 a year. The price fields are not changed here. Not tested: the gift picker (Give customers a choice of products), gift banners, upsells, the Koala Bundles tab, Kopa AI, the Advanced and Plus plans, the real checkout, analytics and live chat. Clean up: the embed was not saved. The offer and the plan went with the uninstall. Our own tab was closed. No kit records were entered. A check of this export route with synthetic records, on the account and date stated. Re-importing the export was not tested. The exported file was not opened, so what it contains is unverified. Friction is described, not scored; this is not a verdict on the product.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#exit-test"
   },
   "export_direct_download": {
    "value": "not_tested",
    "basis": "No explicit observation in the public evidence.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#hands-on"
   },
   "marketing_emails_14d": {
    "value": "not_tested",
    "basis": "No complete unambiguous 14-day inbox observation available.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence_url": null
   }
  }
 },
 "task_evidence": {
  "structured_checks": [],
  "sessions": [
   {
    "source": "session",
    "product_name": "Koala Gifts",
    "product_id": "koala-gifts",
    "run_date": "2026-11-17",
    "session_type": "hands_on",
    "what": "Daan created the account and our AI assistant ran the test in Daan's browser. On 17 November 2026 the session tested Koala Upsells & Gifts (listed as Koala Upsell Free Gift & BOGO) on a Shopify development store: the install through the install form, the plan wall (no free plan), the Basic Monthly test charge (approved without a card, billed 0 dollars), one free gift offer (Demo Shirt for Demo Mug) that stood in the cart as Demo Shirt $19.00 $0.00 FREE GIFT in an unsaved theme preview about 3 minutes and 9 steps after the install, the contradiction on the offer screen (Not visible, activation needed and Great job - your offer is live!), and the uninstall with a required reason. The gift picker, upsells, the Advanced and Plus plans and the real checkout were not tested. Nothing was paid. Install: the App Store listing is apps.shopify.com/upsell-koala-gift, titled Koala Upsell Free Gift & BOGO, by ProfitKoala, with From $9.99/month. Free trial available. and a rating of 5.0 from 396 reviews; the address apps.shopify.com/koala-gifts does not exist. In the Shopify admin the app is called Koala Upsells & Gifts. The app was installed through the install form with the target set to the same tab, in our own tab, at 21:38. The screen Install app said that the app needs access to View customer data, View staff and contributor data and View and edit store data (Products, orders, discounts, Online Store); Install was clicked. There was no separate account or password: the app opened at once on Choose your plan. Plan wall: there is no free plan and nothing could be built before a plan was chosen. The plan was activated at 21:39 after the Shopify approval screen (see Checkout); the dashboard then said Plan activated successfully!, with Theme status 0/3 app blocks added to theme and a Setup guide at 0 / 4 steps completed. Core action, a free gift added automatically: Create a Gift Offer, then Select gift offer exposure with four options, of which Add a gift to customer's cart automatically was chosen, then New gift offer with the default name Buy One Product to get a Free Gift!. The trigger was Specific Product, Demo Mug ($9.50), and the reward was Demo Shirt ($19.00) at Free. Save gave Offer created successfully!. Visibility: right after saving, the same screen showed the status Not visible, the warning Koala Upsells & Gifts app needs activation in theme settings with Your offers aren't available on your product page, and at the same time a card saying Great job - your offer is live!. These contradict each other: the offer is only visible once the app embed is switched on in the theme. In the theme editor (preview with the app embeds) the embed Koala Gifts was switched on and NOT saved. In the unsaved preview, adding Demo Mug to the cart gave a cart with Demo Shirt $19.00 $0.00 FREE GIFT and Demo Mug $9.50. The editor was left with Leave page, so nothing was saved. No gift widget was seen on the product page itself, only in the cart. From the install at 21:38 to the free gift in the cart at 21:41 took about 3 minutes and about 9 steps (choose and approve the plan, choose the offer type, trigger, gift, save, switch on the embed, open the product, add to cart). The checkout of the store was not opened. Plans in the app (Choose your plan, with the line The price for your plan will be based on your Shopify plan): Basic Monthly, $19.99 struck through and $9.99 a month, Start 14-day free trial, with the badge Save up to 50%; Basic Annual, $19.99 struck through and $7.99 a month, Billed yearly, with the badges Save up to 60% and Priority support. Both say You won't be charged before your trial ends. Cancel anytime. The features listed are pop-up upsells on add to cart click, product add-ons and gift banners, gifts added to the cart automatically, rules by customer location and historical purchases, block designs, unlimited gifted products and upsell revenue, and live chat. The Advanced and Plus prices were not seen because the development store is on Basic. Checkout: Start 14-day free trial on Basic Monthly opened the Shopify screen Approve subscription with the notice You will not be billed for this test charge., Basic Monthly, $19,99 struck through and $9,99 USD every 30 days, a label $10,00 off all charges, You have a 14-day free trial ending on 1 Dec., Subtotal $19,99 plus any applicable taxes, Discount $10,00 off, Total $9,99 Due 1 Dec, and a row Add payment method that did not have to be filled in. Approve worked without a card and was clicked: a test charge was approved, no card was entered and no payment method was added, and nothing was billed. The Basic Annual screen was not opened. Cancelling: the route in the app was not looked for. In Shopify, Settings, Apps, the menu next to the app has Uninstall; its dialog says You'll no longer be able to use the app, that data managed by the app, such as discounts, will be deleted, and that a request goes to the developer within 48 hours to delete all personal customer information. A reason for uninstalling is required (Testing multiple apps was chosen). The app was uninstalled at 21:44 (You've successfully uninstalled Koala Upsells & Gifts) and the subscription lapses with it. Differences from the review: the listing and the dossier say the app is free for development stores, but the app asked for a plan and a test charge before anything could be built. The strikethrough $19.99 on both plans is not in the dossier, and the annual plan is shown as $7.99 a month billed yearly, which makes $95.88 a year. The price fields are not changed here. Not tested: the gift picker (Give customers a choice of products), gift banners, upsells, the Koala Bundles tab, Kopa AI, the Advanced and Plus plans, the real checkout, analytics and live chat. Clean up: the embed was not saved. The offer and the plan went with the uninstall. Our own tab was closed. No kit records were entered.",
    "findings": [
     "Text we checked: \"Basic, $9.99 a month, 14-day free trial\". What we saw: The Choose your plan screen shows Basic Monthly at $9.99 a month with $19.99 struck through and Start 14-day free trial. The Shopify approval screen showed $19,99 struck through and $9,99 USD every 30 days with a label $10,00 off all charges, a 14-day free trial ending on 1 Dec. and Total $9,99 Due 1 Dec plus any applicable taxes. How long the $10 discount lasts was not shown.",
     "Text we checked: \"$95.88 a year\". What we saw: The Basic Annual card shows $7.99 a month, Billed yearly, with $19.99 struck through. Twelve times $7.99 is $95.88, so the dossier figure follows from the card; the annual approval screen was not opened, so no yearly total was seen on a screen.",
     "Text we checked: \"free for development stores\". What we saw: The app did not open without a plan: the first screen was Choose your plan with only Basic Monthly and Basic Annual, no free plan, and a Basic Monthly test charge had to be approved before the Create a Gift Offer flow opened. No card was needed and nothing was billed.",
     "Text we checked: \"Add a gift to customer's cart automatically\". What we saw: The exposure Add a gift to customer's cart automatically was chosen, the trigger was Specific Product Demo Mug and the gift Demo Shirt at Free; Save gave Offer created successfully!. With the app embed switched on in an unsaved theme preview, adding Demo Mug put Demo Shirt $19.00 $0.00 FREE GIFT in the cart, about 3 minutes and 9 steps after the install. The theme was not saved, no widget was seen on the product page and the checkout was not opened.",
     "Text we checked: \"Great job - your offer is live!\". What we saw: Right after saving, the same screen showed the status Not visible, the warning that the app needs activation in the theme settings and the card Great job - your offer is live!. The offer only showed in the cart after the app embed was switched on in the theme editor."
    ],
    "not_tested": [
     "Original store creation and identity check, which Daan did himself.",
     "The gift picker, gift banners and upsells.",
     "The Koala Bundles tab, Kopa AI, analytics and live chat.",
     "The Advanced and Plus plans and the Basic Annual approval screen.",
     "The checkout of the store and the live store.",
     "Export and reimport.",
     "Session and source-reading date: 17 November 2026. Times are CET. The session started at about 21:38 CET. These are approximate tester observations, not benchmark timings. Midnight timestamps are required date anchors, not measured event times."
    ],
    "report": null,
    "disclosure": null,
    "evidence_status": null,
    "result": "reported",
    "note": "Findings as written up after the session; no pass/fail per task was scored.",
    "claim_checks": [
     {
      "claim": "Basic, $9.99 a month, 14-day free trial",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "The Choose your plan screen shows Basic Monthly at $9.99 a month with $19.99 struck through and Start 14-day free trial. The Shopify approval screen showed $19,99 struck through and $9,99 USD every 30 days with a label $10,00 off all charges, a 14-day free trial ending on 1 Dec. and Total $9,99 Due 1 Dec plus any applicable taxes. How long the $10 discount lasts was not shown.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Basic Monthly test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
      "comparability": "The dossier price against the plan card and the approval screen; the length of the discount and the taxes were not shown.",
      "status": "confirmed",
      "buying_consequence": "Basic costs $9.99 a month after a 14-day trial, but the list price shown is $19.99 and it is not shown how long the $10 discount runs.",
      "buyer_direction": "neutral",
      "claim_changed_on": null
     },
     {
      "claim": "$95.88 a year",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "The Basic Annual card shows $7.99 a month, Billed yearly, with $19.99 struck through. Twelve times $7.99 is $95.88, so the dossier figure follows from the card; the annual approval screen was not opened, so no yearly total was seen on a screen.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Basic Monthly test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
      "comparability": "The dossier yearly price against a calculation from the Basic Annual card; no yearly approval screen was seen.",
      "status": "confirmed",
      "buying_consequence": "The yearly plan comes to $95.88 a year by calculation; no yearly total was seen on a screen.",
      "buyer_direction": "neutral",
      "claim_changed_on": null
     },
     {
      "claim": "free for development stores",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "The app did not open without a plan: the first screen was Choose your plan with only Basic Monthly and Basic Annual, no free plan, and a Basic Monthly test charge had to be approved before the Create a Gift Offer flow opened. No card was needed and nothing was billed.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Basic Monthly test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
      "comparability": "The dossier wording against the first screen and the approval screen on one development store.",
      "status": "contradicted",
      "buying_consequence": "The app is not free for a development store in the sense that a plan and a test charge are needed first; no card was needed.",
      "buyer_direction": "unfavourable",
      "claim_changed_on": null
     },
     {
      "claim": "Add a gift to customer's cart automatically",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "The exposure Add a gift to customer's cart automatically was chosen, the trigger was Specific Product Demo Mug and the gift Demo Shirt at Free; Save gave Offer created successfully!. With the app embed switched on in an unsaved theme preview, adding Demo Mug put Demo Shirt $19.00 $0.00 FREE GIFT in the cart, about 3 minutes and 9 steps after the install. The theme was not saved, no widget was seen on the product page and the checkout was not opened.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Basic Monthly test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
      "comparability": "The claim that the gift is added automatically against the cart drawer of an unsaved theme preview; the checkout and the live store were not seen.",
      "status": "confirmed",
      "buying_consequence": "A free gift can be added to the cart automatically in a few minutes; it was seen in the cart of a preview and not in the checkout.",
      "buyer_direction": "neutral",
      "claim_changed_on": null
     },
     {
      "claim": "Great job - your offer is live!",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "Right after saving, the same screen showed the status Not visible, the warning that the app needs activation in the theme settings and the card Great job - your offer is live!. The offer only showed in the cart after the app embed was switched on in the theme editor.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Basic Monthly test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
      "comparability": "Card text versus the status badge and warning on the same app screen and the cart in the theme preview.",
      "status": "contradicted",
      "buying_consequence": "A new offer is not visible to shoppers until the theme embed is switched on, although the card says it is live.",
      "buyer_direction": "unfavourable",
      "claim_changed_on": null
     },
     {
      "claim": "$19,99 $9,99 USD every 30 days",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "The plan card showed Basic Monthly at $9.99 a month with $19.99 struck through. The Shopify approval screen said $19,99 struck through and $9,99 USD every 30 days, Subtotal $19,99, Discount $10,00 off, Total $9,99 Due 1 Dec plus any applicable taxes, and was approved as a test charge without a card. Card and approval screen agree; tax is unknown.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/koala-gifts-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Basic Monthly test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
      "comparability": "The plan card against the Shopify approval screen for the same plan; the same amount, no tax line was shown and no stored cost rule was compared.",
      "status": "confirmed",
      "buying_consequence": "The first bill of $9.99 is due on 1 Dec after the trial, before taxes; the list price is $19.99.",
      "buyer_direction": "neutral",
      "claim_changed_on": null
     }
    ],
    "claim_checks_note": "A vendor claim (quoted, with source and read date) set against what we observed in this session on the plan stated. status is confirmed, contradicted, not_comparable, not_testable or out_of_date; it is not a score of the product.",
    "exit_test": {
     "run_date": "2026-11-17",
     "what": "Daan created the account and our AI assistant ran the test in Daan's browser. On 17 November 2026 the session tested Koala Upsells & Gifts (listed as Koala Upsell Free Gift & BOGO) on a Shopify development store: the install through the install form, the plan wall (no free plan), the Basic Monthly test charge (approved without a card, billed 0 dollars), one free gift offer (Demo Shirt for Demo Mug) that stood in the cart as Demo Shirt $19.00 $0.00 FREE GIFT in an unsaved theme preview about 3 minutes and 9 steps after the install, the contradiction on the offer screen (Not visible, activation needed and Great job - your offer is live!), and the uninstall with a required reason. The gift picker, upsells, the Advanced and Plus plans and the real checkout were not tested. Nothing was paid. Install: the App Store listing is apps.shopify.com/upsell-koala-gift, titled Koala Upsell Free Gift & BOGO, by ProfitKoala, with From $9.99/month. Free trial available. and a rating of 5.0 from 396 reviews; the address apps.shopify.com/koala-gifts does not exist. In the Shopify admin the app is called Koala Upsells & Gifts. The app was installed through the install form with the target set to the same tab, in our own tab, at 21:38. The screen Install app said that the app needs access to View customer data, View staff and contributor data and View and edit store data (Products, orders, discounts, Online Store); Install was clicked. There was no separate account or password: the app opened at once on Choose your plan. Plan wall: there is no free plan and nothing could be built before a plan was chosen. The plan was activated at 21:39 after the Shopify approval screen (see Checkout); the dashboard then said Plan activated successfully!, with Theme status 0/3 app blocks added to theme and a Setup guide at 0 / 4 steps completed. Core action, a free gift added automatically: Create a Gift Offer, then Select gift offer exposure with four options, of which Add a gift to customer's cart automatically was chosen, then New gift offer with the default name Buy One Product to get a Free Gift!. The trigger was Specific Product, Demo Mug ($9.50), and the reward was Demo Shirt ($19.00) at Free. Save gave Offer created successfully!. Visibility: right after saving, the same screen showed the status Not visible, the warning Koala Upsells & Gifts app needs activation in theme settings with Your offers aren't available on your product page, and at the same time a card saying Great job - your offer is live!. These contradict each other: the offer is only visible once the app embed is switched on in the theme. In the theme editor (preview with the app embeds) the embed Koala Gifts was switched on and NOT saved. In the unsaved preview, adding Demo Mug to the cart gave a cart with Demo Shirt $19.00 $0.00 FREE GIFT and Demo Mug $9.50. The editor was left with Leave page, so nothing was saved. No gift widget was seen on the product page itself, only in the cart. From the install at 21:38 to the free gift in the cart at 21:41 took about 3 minutes and about 9 steps (choose and approve the plan, choose the offer type, trigger, gift, save, switch on the embed, open the product, add to cart). The checkout of the store was not opened. Plans in the app (Choose your plan, with the line The price for your plan will be based on your Shopify plan): Basic Monthly, $19.99 struck through and $9.99 a month, Start 14-day free trial, with the badge Save up to 50%; Basic Annual, $19.99 struck through and $7.99 a month, Billed yearly, with the badges Save up to 60% and Priority support. Both say You won't be charged before your trial ends. Cancel anytime. The features listed are pop-up upsells on add to cart click, product add-ons and gift banners, gifts added to the cart automatically, rules by customer location and historical purchases, block designs, unlimited gifted products and upsell revenue, and live chat. The Advanced and Plus prices were not seen because the development store is on Basic. Checkout: Start 14-day free trial on Basic Monthly opened the Shopify screen Approve subscription with the notice You will not be billed for this test charge., Basic Monthly, $19,99 struck through and $9,99 USD every 30 days, a label $10,00 off all charges, You have a 14-day free trial ending on 1 Dec., Subtotal $19,99 plus any applicable taxes, Discount $10,00 off, Total $9,99 Due 1 Dec, and a row Add payment method that did not have to be filled in. Approve worked without a card and was clicked: a test charge was approved, no card was entered and no payment method was added, and nothing was billed. The Basic Annual screen was not opened. Cancelling: the route in the app was not looked for. In Shopify, Settings, Apps, the menu next to the app has Uninstall; its dialog says You'll no longer be able to use the app, that data managed by the app, such as discounts, will be deleted, and that a request goes to the developer within 48 hours to delete all personal customer information. A reason for uninstalling is required (Testing multiple apps was chosen). The app was uninstalled at 21:44 (You've successfully uninstalled Koala Upsells & Gifts) and the subscription lapses with it. Differences from the review: the listing and the dossier say the app is free for development stores, but the app asked for a plan and a test charge before anything could be built. The strikethrough $19.99 on both plans is not in the dossier, and the annual plan is shown as $7.99 a month billed yearly, which makes $95.88 a year. The price fields are not changed here. Not tested: the gift picker (Give customers a choice of products), gift banners, upsells, the Koala Bundles tab, Kopa AI, the Advanced and Plus plans, the real checkout, analytics and live chat. Clean up: the embed was not saved. The offer and the plan went with the uninstall. Our own tab was closed. No kit records were entered.",
     "first_import": null,
     "file_inspected": false,
     "reimport_tested": false,
     "awkward": "The app does not open without a plan, although the dossier says it is free for development stores. After saving, the offer screen showed Not visible, a warning that the app needs activation in the theme settings and Great job - your offer is live! at the same time. The gift only showed in the cart, not as a widget on the product page. Uninstalling needs a reason to be chosen.",
     "friction": {
      "export_route": "No export or reimport was performed; no file was downloaded or examined. The two categorised kit records were not entered; the objects tested were not kit records.",
      "format": "No downloaded bytes examined.",
      "reimport": "No reimport performed.",
      "cancellation": "No cancellation or downgrade performed."
     },
     "not_tested": [
      "Original store creation and identity check, which Daan did himself.",
      "The gift picker, gift banners and upsells.",
      "The Koala Bundles tab, Kopa AI, analytics and live chat.",
      "The Advanced and Plus plans and the Basic Annual approval screen.",
      "The checkout of the store and the live store.",
      "Export and reimport.",
      "Session and source-reading date: 17 November 2026. Times are CET. The session started at about 21:38 CET. These are approximate tester observations, not benchmark timings. Midnight timestamps are required date anchors, not measured event times."
     ],
     "available_fields": [],
     "not_offered": [],
     "note": "A check of this export route with synthetic records, on the account and date stated. Re-importing the export was not tested. The exported file was not opened, so what it contains is unverified. Friction is described, not scored; this is not a verdict on the product."
    },
    "in_catalog": true
   }
  ]
 },
 "open_questions": [
  {
   "question_id": "koala-gifts:cancellation_terms",
   "key": "cancellation_terms",
   "question": "Can a customer cancel at any time, and what happens to an annual plan that is cancelled mid-term?",
   "status": "open"
  },
  {
   "question_id": "koala-gifts:data_export",
   "key": "data_export",
   "question": "Which data can a customer export, in which formats, on which plans?",
   "status": "open"
  },
  {
   "question_id": "koala-gifts:data_location",
   "key": "data_location",
   "question": "Where is customer data stored, and can a customer choose the region?",
   "status": "open"
  },
  {
   "question_id": "koala-gifts:pricing_gap_1",
   "key": "pricing_gap_1",
   "question": "Our price check could not put a number on this part of the cost: Special pricing for owners of several stores is on request from support; the rules price each store at the list rate. Can you publish the price or the rule?",
   "status": "open"
  }
 ],
 "vendor_answers": [],
 "agent_channels": {
  "vendor_mcp": null,
  "agent_checkout": {
   "status": "not_found",
   "detail": "No explicit support for purchases by AI agents on the vendor's own pages.",
   "checked_at": "2026-10-07",
   "method": "homepage, /pricing and the pricing page we cite, read as plain HTML (no JavaScript) and searched for explicit support of purchases by AI agents: Agentic Commerce Protocol, Instant Checkout, Agent Payments Protocol, buy in ChatGPT, agentic checkout"
  }
 }
}
