{
 "schema_version": "1.0",
 "id": "bold-upsell",
 "name": "Bold Upsell",
 "research_status": "researched",
 "vendor_domain": "boldcommerce.com",
 "category": "E-commerce",
 "task": "E-commerce growth",
 "summary": "Shopify upsell app by Bold: AI-picked and manual upsells, cross-sells, order bumps, free gifts and subscription offers on product pages, cart and drawer and after purchase, with checkout offers for Shopify Plus stores and an AOV dashboard.",
 "best_for": "Shopify stores on the Basic or Grow plan that want upsells, cross-sells, free gifts and post-purchase offers across product page, cart and thank-you page for a flat monthly fee that does not grow with order volume",
 "skip_if": "your store is on Shopify Advanced and the $74.99 price buys nothing a Basic store does not get; you want in-checkout upsells without Shopify Plus; or you cannot risk an app that edits orders and discounts on a live store without a test window longer than seven days",
 "honest_knock": "Bold Upsell is priced by your Shopify plan, so a store on Shopify Advanced pays $74.99 a month for exactly the feature list a Basic store gets for $4.99, and checkout offers need Shopify Plus at $399.99 a month. The 7-day trial is short for judging an upsell app. The reviews are mostly warm, but 50 of 594 are one- or two-star, and the recent ones are specific: add-to-cart and checkout rates down 70% after offers went live (January 2026), the app failing at its one job with support silent for days or weeks (edited October 2026), and the app stopping without notice (November 2025). The data access is wide, including viewing sensitive customer data and editing orders and discounts. We have not run the app ourselves; this dossier is read from the listing and its reviews.",
 "pricing": {
  "status": "public",
  "entry_price": "$4.99",
  "entry_price_terms": "Shopify Basic · per month, the price follows your Shopify plan: $24.99 on Grow, $74.99 on Advanced, $399.99 on Plus",
  "from_price_usd_month": 4.99,
  "plans": [
   {
    "name": "Shopify Basic",
    "price": "$4.99 a month",
    "includes": "Smart AI upsell offers, cart offers, cross-sells, funnel, post-purchase, free gift, subscription offers, rewards bar"
   },
   {
    "name": "Shopify Grow",
    "price": "$24.99",
    "includes": "Same features as Basic plan"
   },
   {
    "name": "Shopify Advanced",
    "price": "$74.99",
    "includes": "Same features as Basic plan"
   },
   {
    "name": "Shopify Plus",
    "price": "$399.99",
    "includes": "All features plus checkout offers"
   }
  ],
  "plans_source": "summarised from pricing.notes; every plan name and amount appears verbatim in those notes",
  "notes": "(read 2026-10-06 on the Shopify App Store listing at apps.shopify.com/product-upsell, prices in USD) Four plans, and you do not choose between them: each is named after a Shopify plan, so the app costs what your store's own Shopify plan dictates. Shopify Basic is $4.99 a month, Shopify Grow $24.99, Shopify Advanced $74.99 and Shopify Plus $399.99. Each carries a 7-day free trial. The feature list is the same on the first three: Smart AI upsell offers, cart page and cart drawer offers, custom cross-sells and 'true' upsells, funnel offers, post-purchase offers, free gift offers, subscription offers and a rewards announcement bar. The Plus plan adds checkout offers, the only feature that appears on one card alone. The listing calls this flat-rate monthly pricing: nothing is metered on orders, views or the revenue the app generates. All charges are billed in USD, and recurring and usage-based charges are billed every 30 days.",
  "verified_at": "2026-10-06",
  "source_url": null,
  "schema_offer": {
   "price": 4.99,
   "currency": "USD",
   "description": "Shopify Basic, the price follows your Shopify plan: $24.99 on Grow, $74.99 on Advanced, $399.99 on Plus; 7-day free trial; billed every 30 days. Read on the vendor's own pricing page on 2026-10-06.",
   "page": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-upsell-review.html"
  },
  "source_quotes": null,
  "recent_change": null,
  "price_history": {
   "status": "stable",
   "tracked_since": "2026-10-14",
   "last_read": "2026-11-16",
   "read_days": 7,
   "stable": {
    "since": "2026-10-14",
    "until": "2026-11-16",
    "reads": 7,
    "days": 33
   },
   "changes": [],
   "method": "Stable = every amount on the vendor's pricing page identical across >= 3 of our reads over >= 30 days. A change is listed only after we confirmed the new price on the page, with a verbatim quote. Differences in raw readings are never published on their own."
  }
 },
 "free_plan": false,
 "free_plan_evidence": null,
 "cost_traps": [],
 "compare_with": {
  "name": "Selleasy",
  "why": "Selleasy is in our dossiers too, and it prices the opposite way. Read on 19 September 2026, its Shopify listing charges by your store's monthly order count: free up to 50 orders, $9 from 51 to 500, $19 to 1,000 and $29 above that, with a 30-day trial, and the vendor's own page adds a $49 Pro tier that includes checkout upsells for Shopify Plus stores. Bold Upsell ignores order count and follows your Shopify plan: $4.99 on Basic, $74.99 on Advanced, $399.99 on Plus. So a busy store on Shopify Basic is cheaper on Bold ($4.99 against $29), a quieter store on Advanced is cheaper on Selleasy, and a Plus store that wants checkout upsells pays $49 on Selleasy's Pro against $399.99 on Bold. Price both at your own Shopify plan and order count before you choose."
 },
 "links": {
  "record": "https://aibuildermarketplace.com/api/v1/products/bold-upsell.json",
  "review": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-upsell-review.html",
  "marketplace": "https://aibuildermarketplace.com/marketplace/bold-upsell/",
  "vendor_site": "https://boldcommerce.com"
 },
 "purchase": {
  "seller": "the vendor",
  "how": "AIBuilder Marketplace does not sell this software. Sign up, start a trial or buy on the vendor's site.",
  "handoff_url": "https://platform.shoffi.app/r/rl_KPajHLNv",
  "affiliate": true,
  "disclosure": "Where purchase.affiliate is true, purchase.handoff_url is an affiliate link: AIBuilder Marketplace may earn a commission at no extra cost to the buyer. Commission never changes what a record says, and products are not ranked by commission. Where it is false the link is the vendor's plain site."
 },
 "provenance": {
  "research": "hand-researched dossier, read on the vendor's own pages",
  "researched_since": "2026-07",
  "method": "https://aibuildermarketplace.com/how-we-review/",
  "license": "CC BY 4.0. Credit 'AIBuilder Marketplace' with a link to https://aibuildermarketplace.com/atlas/.",
  "note": "A rebuild is not a new measurement: pricing.verified_at is the date that matters."
 },
 "cost": {
  "status": "not_yet",
  "engine": "https://aibuildermarketplace.com/agents/#cost",
  "rules": null,
  "growth": null
 },
 "unknowns": [
  "Data export tested on 2026-11-17; contract terms not researched. Scope and untested export routes are listed in measured.exit_test.",
  "Being verified: free trial and refund terms are not yet matched to a verbatim line on the vendor's own pages. Not matched does not mean there is none.",
  "No computable price rules yet: cost at a given team size cannot be calculated for this product."
 ],
 "verification": {
  "price": "read",
  "free_trial": "being_verified",
  "refund": "being_verified"
 },
 "status_page": null,
 "measured": {
  "support": null,
  "onboarding": null,
  "inbox": {
   "timeline": {
    "signup_at": null,
    "messages": []
   },
   "window_start": "2026-11-16T23:00:00Z",
   "window_end": "2026-11-30T23:00:00Z",
   "window_days": 14,
   "time_basis": "signup_date_midnight_Europe_Amsterdam",
   "status": "partial",
   "observed_at": "2026-11-19T02:18:01.417404Z",
   "counts": {
    "transactional": 0,
    "onboarding_tips": 0,
    "sales_upsell": 0,
    "personal_looking_sales": 0
   },
   "first_sales_email_hours": null,
   "has_list_unsubscribe": false,
   "uncertain": 0,
   "after_cancel": {
    "status": "not_tested"
   },
   "after_deletion": {
    "status": "not_tested"
   },
   "after_unsubscribe": {
    "status": "not_tested"
   }
  },
  "invites": {
   "status": "not_tested",
   "default_on": "not_tested",
   "plus_accepted": "not_tested",
   "invitee_can_unsubscribe": "not_tested",
   "address_book_requested": "not_tested",
   "workspace_requested": "not_tested"
  },
  "entry_exit": {
   "signup": {
    "screens": "not_tested",
    "card_required": "not_tested",
    "call_required": "not_tested",
    "observed_on": null,
    "evidence_url": null
   },
   "cancel": {
    "screens": "not_tested",
    "call_required": "not_tested",
    "observed_on": null,
    "evidence_url": null
   }
  },
  "tested_on": "2026-11-17",
  "tested_by": "Our team; actor, account and scope are documented in the review.",
  "review_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-upsell-review.html",
  "method": [
   "Installed on a Shopify development store, approved the Basic test charge and made one Upsell offer in the app preview",
   "Read the plan screen, then uninstalled the app"
  ],
  "claims": [
   {
    "claim": "Busy stores on the Shopify Basic plan",
    "claim_source": "our test notes",
    "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
    "observed": "About 8 minutes after the install and about 12 clicks from Manual Offers, one Upsell offer was made and shown in the preview inside the app; the app embed was inactive, so it was not seen on the storefront.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence": {
     "label": "Our test observations",
     "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-upsell-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
    },
    "plan": "Basic test charge approved, development store, nothing billed",
    "comparability": "Dossier Basic plan audience wording versus one offer made in the app; the storefront was not seen.",
    "status": "confirmed",
    "buying_consequence": "A first offer can be made in minutes on the Basic plan of the app, but it was only seen in the app preview.",
    "buyer_direction": "neutral",
    "claim_changed_on": null
   },
   {
    "claim": "Shopify Plus stores wanting offers inside checkout",
    "claim_source": "our test notes",
    "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
    "observed": "The offer types in the app include Post-Purchase pages and a Funnel, but no checkout offer was made and the store was not on Plus, so offers inside checkout could not be checked.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence": {
     "label": "Our test observations",
     "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-upsell-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
    },
    "plan": "Basic test charge approved, development store, nothing billed",
    "comparability": "Dossier Plus checkout wording versus a development store on a Basic test plan.",
    "status": "not_testable",
    "buying_consequence": "The test says nothing about offers inside checkout for Plus stores.",
    "buyer_direction": "neutral",
    "claim_changed_on": null
   },
   {
    "claim": "Stores on Shopify Advanced",
    "claim_source": "our test notes",
    "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
    "observed": "The app showed only the Basic plan and the store was on a Basic test plan, so nothing about stores on Shopify Advanced could be tried.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence": {
     "label": "Our test observations",
     "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-upsell-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
    },
    "plan": "Basic test charge approved, development store, nothing billed",
    "comparability": "Dossier Advanced audience wording versus a development store with a Basic test plan.",
    "status": "not_testable",
    "buying_consequence": "The test says nothing about Shopify Advanced stores or the other app plans.",
    "buyer_direction": "neutral",
    "claim_changed_on": null
   },
   {
    "claim": "Basic $4.99 /month",
    "claim_source": "our test notes",
    "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
    "observed": "The app shows one plan, Basic $4.99 /month, which agrees with the App Store; the other plans of the listing were not shown in the app.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence": {
     "label": "Our test observations",
     "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-upsell-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
    },
    "plan": "Basic test charge approved, development store, nothing billed",
    "comparability": "Dossier Basic price versus the Basic card in the app; the other plans were not shown.",
    "status": "confirmed",
    "buying_consequence": "The entry price of the Basic plan matches the listing; the higher plans were not seen.",
    "buyer_direction": "neutral",
    "claim_changed_on": null
   },
   {
    "claim": "You have a 7-day free trial ending on 24 Nov.",
    "claim_source": "our test notes",
    "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
    "observed": "The Shopify approval screen for Basic says a 7-day free trial ending on 24 Nov. and a test charge that is not billed; it was approved without a payment method and nothing was billed.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence": {
     "label": "Our test observations",
     "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-upsell-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
    },
    "plan": "Basic test charge approved, development store, nothing billed",
    "comparability": "Trial wording on the approval screen versus a development store where the test charge is not billed.",
    "status": "not_comparable",
    "buying_consequence": "A trial of 7 days is shown, and a development store is not billed; what a normal store pays after the trial was not tested.",
    "buyer_direction": "neutral",
    "claim_changed_on": null
   },
   {
    "claim": "App Embed Status: Inactive",
    "claim_source": "our test notes",
    "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
    "observed": "The Manual Offers page says the app embed is inactive and asks for it to be enabled in the theme; we did not enable it, so the display of the offer on the storefront was not tested.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence": {
     "label": "Our test observations",
     "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-upsell-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
    },
    "plan": "Basic test charge approved, development store, nothing billed",
    "comparability": "Dossier storefront wording versus an inactive app embed and other upsell apps also switched on in the store.",
    "status": "not_testable",
    "buying_consequence": "The test says nothing about how the offer looks or works on the storefront.",
    "buyer_direction": "neutral",
    "claim_changed_on": null
   },
   {
    "claim": "$4,99 USD every 30 days",
    "claim_source": "our test notes",
    "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
    "observed": "The Shopify approval screen shows $4,99 USD every 30 days and a total of $4,99 due 24 Nov plus any applicable taxes; the Basic card shows $4.99 /month; the screen said it was a test charge and nothing was billed.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence": {
     "label": "Our test observations",
     "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-upsell-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
    },
    "plan": "Basic test charge approved, development store, nothing billed",
    "comparability": "Basic card price versus the approval screen amount; no stored cost rule was compared.",
    "status": "confirmed",
    "buying_consequence": "The price on the Basic card matches the approval screen, with taxes on top.",
    "buyer_direction": "neutral",
    "claim_changed_on": null
   }
  ],
  "exit_test": {
   "run_date": "2026-11-17",
   "what": "The app was installed on our Shopify development store, which Daan set up, and our AI assistant ran the test in Daan's browser. On 17 November 2026 the session tested Bold Upsell (in the admin Bold Product Upsell) on a Shopify development store: the install, the Basic test charge approved without a payment method, one Upsell offer made in about 8 minutes and seen only in the preview inside the app (the app embed stayed inactive and other upsell apps were also switched on in the store), the plan shown in the app and the uninstall dialog, after which the app was uninstalled. Nothing was billed. Install: the install button of the App Store listing was pressed at 14:34 in our own tab; Shopify showed the Install app dialog with View customer data, View staff and contributor data and View and edit store data, and the install was approved. The app opened on a login page and then a plan selection at about 14:35. In the admin the app is called Bold Product Upsell, while the App Store listing says Bold AI Upsell & Cross-Sell. Our development store also had other upsell apps switched on; everything below comes from the Bold app or the Bold install and approval screens. Approval: the plan selection showed one plan, Basic $4.99 /month (Boost your average order value from day one with Bold Upsell), with the button Get Started for Free. This led to a Shopify Approve subscription screen: You will not be billed for this test charge., plan Basic, $4,99 USD every 30 days, You have a 7-day free trial ending on 24 Nov., Subtotal $4,99, Total $4,99 Due 24 Nov. An Add payment method row was shown but not required. Because the screen said it was a test charge, we approved it at 14:36; no payment method was entered and nothing was billed. Core action, one upsell offer, about 8 minutes (14:34 to 14:42) after the install and about 12 clicks from Manual Offers: an onboarding Enable the Bold Upsell App Embed in three steps (Configure your theme, Choose your offer type, Configure your offer) was continued without opening the theme editor; then Setting up your Smart Offers and Smart Offers Queued (We're still learning about your store! To give you the best offers, we need a bit more order data.). Under Manual Offers, Create Your First Offer, Choose Offer Type (Cross-sell Buy X Get Y, Upsell, Post-Purchase Thank You Page, Post-Purchase Email, Free Gift, Funnel, Rewards Bar, Bundles and subscription offers), we picked Upsell, then Configure & Style: Offer Name Snowboard upgrade, Location Product Page (Only one location available), Trigger Products All products selected, Offer Products 1 product selected (The 3p Fulfilled Snowboard $2629.95). The preview inside the app, a pop-up, showed Want to upgrade?, Accepting this offer will replace the original item in your cart with the offer below., a button Replace item and a link No thanks, at about 14:41. Create Offer gave Offer created successfully. and the list showed Snowboard upgrade, Upsell, Product Page Pop-up, Views 0, Conversions 0, Revenue $0.00, Active, at about 14:42. The banner said App Embed Status: Inactive, Action required to display upsells on your storefront. Please enable the Bold Upsell App Embed in your theme. We did not switch the embed on, so the offer was NOT seen on the storefront; only the preview inside the app was seen, and no theme change was saved. Plans: the app showed only the Basic plan at $4.99 /month, which agrees with the App Store; the other plans of the listing (Grow, Advanced, Plus) were not shown in the app. Cancelling: no payment was ever due and the trial was not cancelled separately. The app was uninstalled via Settings, Apps, the row Bold Product Upsell and Uninstall; the dialog says you will no longer be able to use the app, that data managed by the app, such as discounts, will be deleted, and that a request goes to the app developer within 48 hours to delete all personal customer information; a reason is required, we gave Testing multiple apps, and at about 14:48 the app was gone from the installed apps. No separate account, demo, call or phone number was asked. Not tested: the storefront display (the app embed was not switched on), offers in the cart or drawer, post-purchase offers, checkout offers for Plus, Smart Offers (no order data yet), the plans Grow, Advanced and Plus, and a real conversion. Clean up: no theme changes were saved; only the offer Snowboard upgrade existed in the app and went away with the uninstall; other apps were not touched; our own tabs were closed. No kit records were entered.",
   "first_import": null,
   "file_inspected": false,
   "reimport_tested": false,
   "awkward": "The onboarding wants the app embed switched on in the theme before anything shows on the storefront, the Smart Offers need more order data, the app shows only the Basic plan, and other upsell apps were also switched on in the store.",
   "friction": {
    "export_route": "No export or reimport was performed; no file was downloaded or examined. The two categorised kit records were not entered; the objects tested were not kit records.",
    "format": "No downloaded bytes examined.",
    "reimport": "No reimport performed.",
    "cancellation": "No cancellation or downgrade performed."
   },
   "not_tested": [
    "Original store creation and identity check, which Daan did himself.",
    "The offer on the storefront, because the app embed was not switched on and no theme change was saved.",
    "Offers in the cart or drawer, post-purchase offers and checkout offers for Plus.",
    "Smart Offers, which needed more order data.",
    "The plans Grow, Advanced and Plus, which the app did not show.",
    "A real conversion.",
    "Export and reimport.",
    "Session and source-reading date: 17 November 2026. Times are CET. The session started at about 14:34 CET. These are approximate tester observations, not benchmark timings. Midnight timestamps are required date anchors, not measured event times."
   ],
   "available_fields": [],
   "not_offered": [],
   "note": "A check of this export route with synthetic records, on the account and date stated. Re-importing the export was not tested. The exported file was not opened, so what it contains is unverified. Friction is described, not scored; this is not a verdict on the product.",
   "evidence_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-upsell-review.html#exit-test"
  },
  "facts": {
   "trial_requires_card": {
    "value": "not_tested",
    "basis": "No explicit observation in the public evidence.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-upsell-review.html#hands-on"
   },
   "trial_duration_confirmed": {
    "value": "not_tested",
    "basis": "No explicit observation in the public evidence.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-upsell-review.html#hands-on"
   },
   "export_file_inspected": {
    "value": false,
    "basis": "The app was installed on our Shopify development store, which Daan set up, and our AI assistant ran the test in Daan's browser. On 17 November 2026 the session tested Bold Upsell (in the admin Bold Product Upsell) on a Shopify development store: the install, the Basic test charge approved without a payment method, one Upsell offer made in about 8 minutes and seen only in the preview inside the app (the app embed stayed inactive and other upsell apps were also switched on in the store), the plan shown in the app and the uninstall dialog, after which the app was uninstalled. Nothing was billed. Install: the install button of the App Store listing was pressed at 14:34 in our own tab; Shopify showed the Install app dialog with View customer data, View staff and contributor data and View and edit store data, and the install was approved. The app opened on a login page and then a plan selection at about 14:35. In the admin the app is called Bold Product Upsell, while the App Store listing says Bold AI Upsell & Cross-Sell. Our development store also had other upsell apps switched on; everything below comes from the Bold app or the Bold install and approval screens. Approval: the plan selection showed one plan, Basic $4.99 /month (Boost your average order value from day one with Bold Upsell), with the button Get Started for Free. This led to a Shopify Approve subscription screen: You will not be billed for this test charge., plan Basic, $4,99 USD every 30 days, You have a 7-day free trial ending on 24 Nov., Subtotal $4,99, Total $4,99 Due 24 Nov. An Add payment method row was shown but not required. Because the screen said it was a test charge, we approved it at 14:36; no payment method was entered and nothing was billed. Core action, one upsell offer, about 8 minutes (14:34 to 14:42) after the install and about 12 clicks from Manual Offers: an onboarding Enable the Bold Upsell App Embed in three steps (Configure your theme, Choose your offer type, Configure your offer) was continued without opening the theme editor; then Setting up your Smart Offers and Smart Offers Queued (We're still learning about your store! To give you the best offers, we need a bit more order data.). Under Manual Offers, Create Your First Offer, Choose Offer Type (Cross-sell Buy X Get Y, Upsell, Post-Purchase Thank You Page, Post-Purchase Email, Free Gift, Funnel, Rewards Bar, Bundles and subscription offers), we picked Upsell, then Configure & Style: Offer Name Snowboard upgrade, Location Product Page (Only one location available), Trigger Products All products selected, Offer Products 1 product selected (The 3p Fulfilled Snowboard $2629.95). The preview inside the app, a pop-up, showed Want to upgrade?, Accepting this offer will replace the original item in your cart with the offer below., a button Replace item and a link No thanks, at about 14:41. Create Offer gave Offer created successfully. and the list showed Snowboard upgrade, Upsell, Product Page Pop-up, Views 0, Conversions 0, Revenue $0.00, Active, at about 14:42. The banner said App Embed Status: Inactive, Action required to display upsells on your storefront. Please enable the Bold Upsell App Embed in your theme. We did not switch the embed on, so the offer was NOT seen on the storefront; only the preview inside the app was seen, and no theme change was saved. Plans: the app showed only the Basic plan at $4.99 /month, which agrees with the App Store; the other plans of the listing (Grow, Advanced, Plus) were not shown in the app. Cancelling: no payment was ever due and the trial was not cancelled separately. The app was uninstalled via Settings, Apps, the row Bold Product Upsell and Uninstall; the dialog says you will no longer be able to use the app, that data managed by the app, such as discounts, will be deleted, and that a request goes to the app developer within 48 hours to delete all personal customer information; a reason is required, we gave Testing multiple apps, and at about 14:48 the app was gone from the installed apps. No separate account, demo, call or phone number was asked. Not tested: the storefront display (the app embed was not switched on), offers in the cart or drawer, post-purchase offers, checkout offers for Plus, Smart Offers (no order data yet), the plans Grow, Advanced and Plus, and a real conversion. Clean up: no theme changes were saved; only the offer Snowboard upgrade existed in the app and went away with the uninstall; other apps were not touched; our own tabs were closed. No kit records were entered. A check of this export route with synthetic records, on the account and date stated. Re-importing the export was not tested. The exported file was not opened, so what it contains is unverified. Friction is described, not scored; this is not a verdict on the product.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-upsell-review.html#exit-test"
   },
   "export_reimport_tested": {
    "value": false,
    "basis": "The app was installed on our Shopify development store, which Daan set up, and our AI assistant ran the test in Daan's browser. On 17 November 2026 the session tested Bold Upsell (in the admin Bold Product Upsell) on a Shopify development store: the install, the Basic test charge approved without a payment method, one Upsell offer made in about 8 minutes and seen only in the preview inside the app (the app embed stayed inactive and other upsell apps were also switched on in the store), the plan shown in the app and the uninstall dialog, after which the app was uninstalled. Nothing was billed. Install: the install button of the App Store listing was pressed at 14:34 in our own tab; Shopify showed the Install app dialog with View customer data, View staff and contributor data and View and edit store data, and the install was approved. The app opened on a login page and then a plan selection at about 14:35. In the admin the app is called Bold Product Upsell, while the App Store listing says Bold AI Upsell & Cross-Sell. Our development store also had other upsell apps switched on; everything below comes from the Bold app or the Bold install and approval screens. Approval: the plan selection showed one plan, Basic $4.99 /month (Boost your average order value from day one with Bold Upsell), with the button Get Started for Free. This led to a Shopify Approve subscription screen: You will not be billed for this test charge., plan Basic, $4,99 USD every 30 days, You have a 7-day free trial ending on 24 Nov., Subtotal $4,99, Total $4,99 Due 24 Nov. An Add payment method row was shown but not required. Because the screen said it was a test charge, we approved it at 14:36; no payment method was entered and nothing was billed. Core action, one upsell offer, about 8 minutes (14:34 to 14:42) after the install and about 12 clicks from Manual Offers: an onboarding Enable the Bold Upsell App Embed in three steps (Configure your theme, Choose your offer type, Configure your offer) was continued without opening the theme editor; then Setting up your Smart Offers and Smart Offers Queued (We're still learning about your store! To give you the best offers, we need a bit more order data.). Under Manual Offers, Create Your First Offer, Choose Offer Type (Cross-sell Buy X Get Y, Upsell, Post-Purchase Thank You Page, Post-Purchase Email, Free Gift, Funnel, Rewards Bar, Bundles and subscription offers), we picked Upsell, then Configure & Style: Offer Name Snowboard upgrade, Location Product Page (Only one location available), Trigger Products All products selected, Offer Products 1 product selected (The 3p Fulfilled Snowboard $2629.95). The preview inside the app, a pop-up, showed Want to upgrade?, Accepting this offer will replace the original item in your cart with the offer below., a button Replace item and a link No thanks, at about 14:41. Create Offer gave Offer created successfully. and the list showed Snowboard upgrade, Upsell, Product Page Pop-up, Views 0, Conversions 0, Revenue $0.00, Active, at about 14:42. The banner said App Embed Status: Inactive, Action required to display upsells on your storefront. Please enable the Bold Upsell App Embed in your theme. We did not switch the embed on, so the offer was NOT seen on the storefront; only the preview inside the app was seen, and no theme change was saved. Plans: the app showed only the Basic plan at $4.99 /month, which agrees with the App Store; the other plans of the listing (Grow, Advanced, Plus) were not shown in the app. Cancelling: no payment was ever due and the trial was not cancelled separately. The app was uninstalled via Settings, Apps, the row Bold Product Upsell and Uninstall; the dialog says you will no longer be able to use the app, that data managed by the app, such as discounts, will be deleted, and that a request goes to the app developer within 48 hours to delete all personal customer information; a reason is required, we gave Testing multiple apps, and at about 14:48 the app was gone from the installed apps. No separate account, demo, call or phone number was asked. Not tested: the storefront display (the app embed was not switched on), offers in the cart or drawer, post-purchase offers, checkout offers for Plus, Smart Offers (no order data yet), the plans Grow, Advanced and Plus, and a real conversion. Clean up: no theme changes were saved; only the offer Snowboard upgrade existed in the app and went away with the uninstall; other apps were not touched; our own tabs were closed. No kit records were entered. A check of this export route with synthetic records, on the account and date stated. Re-importing the export was not tested. The exported file was not opened, so what it contains is unverified. Friction is described, not scored; this is not a verdict on the product.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-upsell-review.html#exit-test"
   },
   "export_direct_download": {
    "value": "not_tested",
    "basis": "No explicit observation in the public evidence.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-upsell-review.html#hands-on"
   },
   "marketing_emails_14d": {
    "value": "not_tested",
    "basis": "No complete unambiguous 14-day inbox observation available.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-19",
    "evidence_url": null
   }
  }
 },
 "task_evidence": {
  "structured_checks": [],
  "sessions": [
   {
    "source": "session",
    "product_name": "Bold Upsell",
    "product_id": "bold-upsell",
    "run_date": "2026-11-17",
    "session_type": "hands_on",
    "what": "The app was installed on our Shopify development store, which Daan set up, and our AI assistant ran the test in Daan's browser. On 17 November 2026 the session tested Bold Upsell (in the admin Bold Product Upsell) on a Shopify development store: the install, the Basic test charge approved without a payment method, one Upsell offer made in about 8 minutes and seen only in the preview inside the app (the app embed stayed inactive and other upsell apps were also switched on in the store), the plan shown in the app and the uninstall dialog, after which the app was uninstalled. Nothing was billed. Install: the install button of the App Store listing was pressed at 14:34 in our own tab; Shopify showed the Install app dialog with View customer data, View staff and contributor data and View and edit store data, and the install was approved. The app opened on a login page and then a plan selection at about 14:35. In the admin the app is called Bold Product Upsell, while the App Store listing says Bold AI Upsell & Cross-Sell. Our development store also had other upsell apps switched on; everything below comes from the Bold app or the Bold install and approval screens. Approval: the plan selection showed one plan, Basic $4.99 /month (Boost your average order value from day one with Bold Upsell), with the button Get Started for Free. This led to a Shopify Approve subscription screen: You will not be billed for this test charge., plan Basic, $4,99 USD every 30 days, You have a 7-day free trial ending on 24 Nov., Subtotal $4,99, Total $4,99 Due 24 Nov. An Add payment method row was shown but not required. Because the screen said it was a test charge, we approved it at 14:36; no payment method was entered and nothing was billed. Core action, one upsell offer, about 8 minutes (14:34 to 14:42) after the install and about 12 clicks from Manual Offers: an onboarding Enable the Bold Upsell App Embed in three steps (Configure your theme, Choose your offer type, Configure your offer) was continued without opening the theme editor; then Setting up your Smart Offers and Smart Offers Queued (We're still learning about your store! To give you the best offers, we need a bit more order data.). Under Manual Offers, Create Your First Offer, Choose Offer Type (Cross-sell Buy X Get Y, Upsell, Post-Purchase Thank You Page, Post-Purchase Email, Free Gift, Funnel, Rewards Bar, Bundles and subscription offers), we picked Upsell, then Configure & Style: Offer Name Snowboard upgrade, Location Product Page (Only one location available), Trigger Products All products selected, Offer Products 1 product selected (The 3p Fulfilled Snowboard $2629.95). The preview inside the app, a pop-up, showed Want to upgrade?, Accepting this offer will replace the original item in your cart with the offer below., a button Replace item and a link No thanks, at about 14:41. Create Offer gave Offer created successfully. and the list showed Snowboard upgrade, Upsell, Product Page Pop-up, Views 0, Conversions 0, Revenue $0.00, Active, at about 14:42. The banner said App Embed Status: Inactive, Action required to display upsells on your storefront. Please enable the Bold Upsell App Embed in your theme. We did not switch the embed on, so the offer was NOT seen on the storefront; only the preview inside the app was seen, and no theme change was saved. Plans: the app showed only the Basic plan at $4.99 /month, which agrees with the App Store; the other plans of the listing (Grow, Advanced, Plus) were not shown in the app. Cancelling: no payment was ever due and the trial was not cancelled separately. The app was uninstalled via Settings, Apps, the row Bold Product Upsell and Uninstall; the dialog says you will no longer be able to use the app, that data managed by the app, such as discounts, will be deleted, and that a request goes to the app developer within 48 hours to delete all personal customer information; a reason is required, we gave Testing multiple apps, and at about 14:48 the app was gone from the installed apps. No separate account, demo, call or phone number was asked. Not tested: the storefront display (the app embed was not switched on), offers in the cart or drawer, post-purchase offers, checkout offers for Plus, Smart Offers (no order data yet), the plans Grow, Advanced and Plus, and a real conversion. Clean up: no theme changes were saved; only the offer Snowboard upgrade existed in the app and went away with the uninstall; other apps were not touched; our own tabs were closed. No kit records were entered.",
    "findings": [
     "Text we checked: \"Busy stores on the Shopify Basic plan\". What we saw: About 8 minutes after the install and about 12 clicks from Manual Offers, one Upsell offer was made and shown in the preview inside the app; the app embed was inactive, so it was not seen on the storefront.",
     "Text we checked: \"Basic $4.99 /month\". What we saw: The app shows one plan, Basic $4.99 /month, which agrees with the App Store; the other plans of the listing were not shown in the app."
    ],
    "not_tested": [
     "Original store creation and identity check, which Daan did himself.",
     "The offer on the storefront, because the app embed was not switched on and no theme change was saved.",
     "Offers in the cart or drawer, post-purchase offers and checkout offers for Plus.",
     "Smart Offers, which needed more order data.",
     "The plans Grow, Advanced and Plus, which the app did not show.",
     "A real conversion.",
     "Export and reimport.",
     "Session and source-reading date: 17 November 2026. Times are CET. The session started at about 14:34 CET. These are approximate tester observations, not benchmark timings. Midnight timestamps are required date anchors, not measured event times."
    ],
    "report": null,
    "disclosure": null,
    "evidence_status": null,
    "result": "reported",
    "note": "Findings as written up after the session; no pass/fail per task was scored.",
    "claim_checks": [
     {
      "claim": "Busy stores on the Shopify Basic plan",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "About 8 minutes after the install and about 12 clicks from Manual Offers, one Upsell offer was made and shown in the preview inside the app; the app embed was inactive, so it was not seen on the storefront.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-upsell-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Basic test charge approved, development store, nothing billed",
      "comparability": "Dossier Basic plan audience wording versus one offer made in the app; the storefront was not seen.",
      "status": "confirmed",
      "buying_consequence": "A first offer can be made in minutes on the Basic plan of the app, but it was only seen in the app preview.",
      "buyer_direction": "neutral",
      "claim_changed_on": null
     },
     {
      "claim": "Shopify Plus stores wanting offers inside checkout",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "The offer types in the app include Post-Purchase pages and a Funnel, but no checkout offer was made and the store was not on Plus, so offers inside checkout could not be checked.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-upsell-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Basic test charge approved, development store, nothing billed",
      "comparability": "Dossier Plus checkout wording versus a development store on a Basic test plan.",
      "status": "not_testable",
      "buying_consequence": "The test says nothing about offers inside checkout for Plus stores.",
      "buyer_direction": "neutral",
      "claim_changed_on": null
     },
     {
      "claim": "Stores on Shopify Advanced",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "The app showed only the Basic plan and the store was on a Basic test plan, so nothing about stores on Shopify Advanced could be tried.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-upsell-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Basic test charge approved, development store, nothing billed",
      "comparability": "Dossier Advanced audience wording versus a development store with a Basic test plan.",
      "status": "not_testable",
      "buying_consequence": "The test says nothing about Shopify Advanced stores or the other app plans.",
      "buyer_direction": "neutral",
      "claim_changed_on": null
     },
     {
      "claim": "Basic $4.99 /month",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "The app shows one plan, Basic $4.99 /month, which agrees with the App Store; the other plans of the listing were not shown in the app.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-upsell-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Basic test charge approved, development store, nothing billed",
      "comparability": "Dossier Basic price versus the Basic card in the app; the other plans were not shown.",
      "status": "confirmed",
      "buying_consequence": "The entry price of the Basic plan matches the listing; the higher plans were not seen.",
      "buyer_direction": "neutral",
      "claim_changed_on": null
     },
     {
      "claim": "You have a 7-day free trial ending on 24 Nov.",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "The Shopify approval screen for Basic says a 7-day free trial ending on 24 Nov. and a test charge that is not billed; it was approved without a payment method and nothing was billed.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-upsell-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Basic test charge approved, development store, nothing billed",
      "comparability": "Trial wording on the approval screen versus a development store where the test charge is not billed.",
      "status": "not_comparable",
      "buying_consequence": "A trial of 7 days is shown, and a development store is not billed; what a normal store pays after the trial was not tested.",
      "buyer_direction": "neutral",
      "claim_changed_on": null
     },
     {
      "claim": "App Embed Status: Inactive",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "The Manual Offers page says the app embed is inactive and asks for it to be enabled in the theme; we did not enable it, so the display of the offer on the storefront was not tested.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-upsell-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Basic test charge approved, development store, nothing billed",
      "comparability": "Dossier storefront wording versus an inactive app embed and other upsell apps also switched on in the store.",
      "status": "not_testable",
      "buying_consequence": "The test says nothing about how the offer looks or works on the storefront.",
      "buyer_direction": "neutral",
      "claim_changed_on": null
     },
     {
      "claim": "$4,99 USD every 30 days",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "The Shopify approval screen shows $4,99 USD every 30 days and a total of $4,99 due 24 Nov plus any applicable taxes; the Basic card shows $4.99 /month; the screen said it was a test charge and nothing was billed.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-upsell-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Basic test charge approved, development store, nothing billed",
      "comparability": "Basic card price versus the approval screen amount; no stored cost rule was compared.",
      "status": "confirmed",
      "buying_consequence": "The price on the Basic card matches the approval screen, with taxes on top.",
      "buyer_direction": "neutral",
      "claim_changed_on": null
     }
    ],
    "claim_checks_note": "A vendor claim (quoted, with source and read date) set against what we observed in this session on the plan stated. status is confirmed, contradicted, not_comparable, not_testable or out_of_date; it is not a score of the product.",
    "exit_test": {
     "run_date": "2026-11-17",
     "what": "The app was installed on our Shopify development store, which Daan set up, and our AI assistant ran the test in Daan's browser. On 17 November 2026 the session tested Bold Upsell (in the admin Bold Product Upsell) on a Shopify development store: the install, the Basic test charge approved without a payment method, one Upsell offer made in about 8 minutes and seen only in the preview inside the app (the app embed stayed inactive and other upsell apps were also switched on in the store), the plan shown in the app and the uninstall dialog, after which the app was uninstalled. Nothing was billed. Install: the install button of the App Store listing was pressed at 14:34 in our own tab; Shopify showed the Install app dialog with View customer data, View staff and contributor data and View and edit store data, and the install was approved. The app opened on a login page and then a plan selection at about 14:35. In the admin the app is called Bold Product Upsell, while the App Store listing says Bold AI Upsell & Cross-Sell. Our development store also had other upsell apps switched on; everything below comes from the Bold app or the Bold install and approval screens. Approval: the plan selection showed one plan, Basic $4.99 /month (Boost your average order value from day one with Bold Upsell), with the button Get Started for Free. This led to a Shopify Approve subscription screen: You will not be billed for this test charge., plan Basic, $4,99 USD every 30 days, You have a 7-day free trial ending on 24 Nov., Subtotal $4,99, Total $4,99 Due 24 Nov. An Add payment method row was shown but not required. Because the screen said it was a test charge, we approved it at 14:36; no payment method was entered and nothing was billed. Core action, one upsell offer, about 8 minutes (14:34 to 14:42) after the install and about 12 clicks from Manual Offers: an onboarding Enable the Bold Upsell App Embed in three steps (Configure your theme, Choose your offer type, Configure your offer) was continued without opening the theme editor; then Setting up your Smart Offers and Smart Offers Queued (We're still learning about your store! To give you the best offers, we need a bit more order data.). Under Manual Offers, Create Your First Offer, Choose Offer Type (Cross-sell Buy X Get Y, Upsell, Post-Purchase Thank You Page, Post-Purchase Email, Free Gift, Funnel, Rewards Bar, Bundles and subscription offers), we picked Upsell, then Configure & Style: Offer Name Snowboard upgrade, Location Product Page (Only one location available), Trigger Products All products selected, Offer Products 1 product selected (The 3p Fulfilled Snowboard $2629.95). The preview inside the app, a pop-up, showed Want to upgrade?, Accepting this offer will replace the original item in your cart with the offer below., a button Replace item and a link No thanks, at about 14:41. Create Offer gave Offer created successfully. and the list showed Snowboard upgrade, Upsell, Product Page Pop-up, Views 0, Conversions 0, Revenue $0.00, Active, at about 14:42. The banner said App Embed Status: Inactive, Action required to display upsells on your storefront. Please enable the Bold Upsell App Embed in your theme. We did not switch the embed on, so the offer was NOT seen on the storefront; only the preview inside the app was seen, and no theme change was saved. Plans: the app showed only the Basic plan at $4.99 /month, which agrees with the App Store; the other plans of the listing (Grow, Advanced, Plus) were not shown in the app. Cancelling: no payment was ever due and the trial was not cancelled separately. The app was uninstalled via Settings, Apps, the row Bold Product Upsell and Uninstall; the dialog says you will no longer be able to use the app, that data managed by the app, such as discounts, will be deleted, and that a request goes to the app developer within 48 hours to delete all personal customer information; a reason is required, we gave Testing multiple apps, and at about 14:48 the app was gone from the installed apps. No separate account, demo, call or phone number was asked. Not tested: the storefront display (the app embed was not switched on), offers in the cart or drawer, post-purchase offers, checkout offers for Plus, Smart Offers (no order data yet), the plans Grow, Advanced and Plus, and a real conversion. Clean up: no theme changes were saved; only the offer Snowboard upgrade existed in the app and went away with the uninstall; other apps were not touched; our own tabs were closed. No kit records were entered.",
     "first_import": null,
     "file_inspected": false,
     "reimport_tested": false,
     "awkward": "The onboarding wants the app embed switched on in the theme before anything shows on the storefront, the Smart Offers need more order data, the app shows only the Basic plan, and other upsell apps were also switched on in the store.",
     "friction": {
      "export_route": "No export or reimport was performed; no file was downloaded or examined. The two categorised kit records were not entered; the objects tested were not kit records.",
      "format": "No downloaded bytes examined.",
      "reimport": "No reimport performed.",
      "cancellation": "No cancellation or downgrade performed."
     },
     "not_tested": [
      "Original store creation and identity check, which Daan did himself.",
      "The offer on the storefront, because the app embed was not switched on and no theme change was saved.",
      "Offers in the cart or drawer, post-purchase offers and checkout offers for Plus.",
      "Smart Offers, which needed more order data.",
      "The plans Grow, Advanced and Plus, which the app did not show.",
      "A real conversion.",
      "Export and reimport.",
      "Session and source-reading date: 17 November 2026. Times are CET. The session started at about 14:34 CET. These are approximate tester observations, not benchmark timings. Midnight timestamps are required date anchors, not measured event times."
     ],
     "available_fields": [],
     "not_offered": [],
     "note": "A check of this export route with synthetic records, on the account and date stated. Re-importing the export was not tested. The exported file was not opened, so what it contains is unverified. Friction is described, not scored; this is not a verdict on the product."
    },
    "in_catalog": true
   }
  ]
 },
 "open_questions": [
  {
   "question_id": "bold-upsell:cancellation_terms",
   "key": "cancellation_terms",
   "question": "Can a customer cancel at any time, and what happens to an annual plan that is cancelled mid-term?",
   "status": "open"
  },
  {
   "question_id": "bold-upsell:data_export",
   "key": "data_export",
   "question": "Which data can a customer export, in which formats, on which plans?",
   "status": "open"
  },
  {
   "question_id": "bold-upsell:data_location",
   "key": "data_location",
   "question": "Where is customer data stored, and can a customer choose the region?",
   "status": "open"
  },
  {
   "question_id": "bold-upsell:minimum_seats",
   "key": "minimum_seats",
   "question": "Is there a minimum number of seats or users on any plan?",
   "status": "open"
  }
 ],
 "vendor_answers": [],
 "agent_channels": {
  "vendor_mcp": null,
  "agent_checkout": {
   "status": "not_checked",
   "detail": "We could not read the vendor's pages as plain HTML.",
   "checked_at": "2026-10-07",
   "method": "homepage, /pricing and the pricing page we cite, read as plain HTML (no JavaScript) and searched for explicit support of purchases by AI agents: Agentic Commerce Protocol, Instant Checkout, Agent Payments Protocol, buy in ChatGPT, agentic checkout"
  }
 }
}
