{
 "schema_version": "1.0",
 "id": "bold-memberships",
 "name": "Bold Memberships",
 "research_status": "researched",
 "vendor_domain": "boldcommerce.com",
 "category": "E-commerce",
 "task": "E-commerce growth",
 "summary": "Shopify membership and loyalty app by Bold: free and paid tiers, store credit, loyalty points, member pricing and free shipping, gated products and checkout, Shopify POS sign-ups and Apple and Google Wallet cards.",
 "best_for": "Shopify stores that want a paid or free membership with store credit, member pricing, free shipping, gated products and checkout, POS sign-ups and wallet cards in one app, and would rather pay per member than a flat monthly fee or a cut of each sale",
 "skip_if": "you want to put a large free loyalty tier in front of your whole customer list on a tight budget (each member costs 13 cents a month); you need paid memberships to show up as Shopify orders; or you cannot accept an app that views sensitive customer data and edits orders and store credit",
 "honest_knock": "Bold Memberships charges for every member, every month: $0.13 each after the first 10, so a free loyalty tier with 10,000 customers costs about $1,300 a month, and the listing does not say whether free members count. Paid tiers run through Stripe rather than Shopify's checkout; a January 2026 review notes that sign-ups do not appear as Shopify orders. The newest reviews are warm about support, but the 1- and 2-star reviews describe member tags vanishing and customers locked out (2021, 2022), members still charged after the app was deleted (2022), and a 2022 complaint about compatibility with modern themes. The data access is wide, including viewing sensitive customer data and editing orders and store credit. We have not run the app ourselves; this dossier is read from the listing, Bold's product page and the reviews.",
 "pricing": {
  "status": "public",
  "entry_price": "$0.13",
  "entry_price_terms": "Scale · per member, per month",
  "from_price_usd_month": 0.13,
  "plans": null,
  "plans_source": null,
  "notes": "(read 2026-10-05 on the Shopify App Store listing at apps.shopify.com/recurring-memberships, prices in USD) One plan, called Scale: free to install, then $0.13 per member per month. The first 10 members are free forever, the first 30 days are free, and the listing says there is no flat monthly base fee and no transaction fee. All charges are billed in USD. The listing does not define a member; we read it as each customer enrolled in one of your membership tiers, free tiers included, and that is worth confirming before you put a free tier in front of your whole customer list. Paid tiers collect their fees through Stripe (Stripe is listed under 'Works with', and an October 2024 review says membership fees are refunded through Stripe), so Stripe's own processing fees come on top of the app bill. Shopify's own charge notice in our test store on 17 November 2026 repeated the $0.13 per active member rate with the first 10 active members free and added that these pay-per-use charges will not go over a maximum of $10,000 per month.",
  "verified_at": "2026-10-05",
  "source_url": "https://apps.shopify.com/recurring-memberships",
  "schema_offer": {
   "price": 0.13,
   "currency": "USD",
   "description": "Scale, per member, per month; first 10 members free forever; no flat monthly base fee and no transaction fee; first 30 days free. Read on the vendor's own pricing page on 2026-10-05.",
   "page": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html"
  },
  "source_quotes": null,
  "recent_change": null,
  "price_history": null
 },
 "free_plan": true,
 "free_plan_evidence": "The first 10 members are free forever, the first 30 days are free, and the listing says there is no flat monthly base fee and no transaction fee.",
 "cost_traps": [
  {
   "id": "per_seat",
   "label": "Per-seat pricing",
   "evidence": "(read 2026-10-05 on the Shopify App Store listing at apps.shopify.com/recurring-memberships, prices in USD) One plan, called Scale: free to install, then $0.13 per member per month.",
   "verified_at": "2026-10-05",
   "source_url": "https://apps.shopify.com/recurring-memberships"
  }
 ],
 "compare_with": {
  "name": "Bold Subscriptions",
  "why": "Bold Subscriptions is in our dossiers too, and Bold builds both; the Memberships listing names it as an integration. They price in opposite ways. Bold Subscriptions sells a product on a schedule and charges $24.99 to $74.99 a month plus a 0.9% to 2% fee on the orders it processes. Bold Memberships sells access and perks, charges $0.13 per member per month with no transaction fee, and takes paid-tier fees through Stripe. If what you sell repeats (coffee, refills, boxes), start with Subscriptions; if what you sell is a status (discounts, early access, member-only products), start with Memberships, and Bold's product page describes running them together, with perks that switch on when a customer subscribes."
 },
 "links": {
  "record": "https://aibuildermarketplace.com/api/v1/products/bold-memberships.json",
  "review": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html",
  "marketplace": "https://aibuildermarketplace.com/marketplace/bold-memberships/",
  "vendor_site": "https://boldcommerce.com"
 },
 "purchase": {
  "seller": "the vendor",
  "how": "AIBuilder Marketplace does not sell this software. Sign up, start a trial or buy on the vendor's site.",
  "handoff_url": "https://boldcommerce.com/",
  "affiliate": false,
  "disclosure": "Where purchase.affiliate is true, purchase.handoff_url is an affiliate link: AIBuilder Marketplace may earn a commission at no extra cost to the buyer. Commission never changes what a record says, and products are not ranked by commission. Where it is false the link is the vendor's plain site."
 },
 "provenance": {
  "research": "hand-researched dossier, read on the vendor's own pages",
  "researched_since": "2026-07",
  "method": "https://aibuildermarketplace.com/how-we-review/",
  "license": "CC BY 4.0. Credit 'AIBuilder Marketplace' with a link to https://aibuildermarketplace.com/atlas/.",
  "note": "A rebuild is not a new measurement: pricing.verified_at is the date that matters."
 },
 "cost": {
  "status": "not_yet",
  "engine": "https://aibuildermarketplace.com/agents/#cost",
  "rules": null,
  "growth": null
 },
 "unknowns": [
  "Plan-by-plan prices are not structured in this record yet; pricing.notes has the full text.",
  "Data export tested on 2026-11-17; contract terms not researched. Scope and untested export routes are listed in measured.exit_test.",
  "Being verified: free trial and refund terms are not yet matched to a verbatim line on the vendor's own pages. Not matched does not mean there is none.",
  "No computable price rules yet: cost at a given team size cannot be calculated for this product."
 ],
 "verification": {
  "price": "read",
  "free_trial": "being_verified",
  "refund": "being_verified"
 },
 "status_page": null,
 "measured": {
  "support": null,
  "onboarding": null,
  "inbox": {
   "timeline": {
    "signup_at": null,
    "messages": []
   },
   "window_start": "2026-11-16T23:00:00Z",
   "window_end": "2026-11-30T23:00:00Z",
   "window_days": 14,
   "time_basis": "signup_date_midnight_Europe_Amsterdam",
   "status": "partial",
   "observed_at": "2026-11-19T02:18:01.417404Z",
   "counts": {
    "transactional": 0,
    "onboarding_tips": 0,
    "sales_upsell": 0,
    "personal_looking_sales": 0
   },
   "first_sales_email_hours": null,
   "has_list_unsubscribe": false,
   "uncertain": 0,
   "after_cancel": {
    "status": "not_tested"
   },
   "after_deletion": {
    "status": "not_tested"
   },
   "after_unsubscribe": {
    "status": "not_tested"
   }
  },
  "invites": {
   "status": "not_tested",
   "default_on": "not_tested",
   "plus_accepted": "not_tested",
   "invitee_can_unsubscribe": "not_tested",
   "address_book_requested": "not_tested",
   "workspace_requested": "not_tested"
  },
  "entry_exit": {
   "signup": {
    "screens": "not_tested",
    "card_required": "not_tested",
    "call_required": "not_tested",
    "observed_on": null,
    "evidence_url": null
   },
   "cancel": {
    "screens": "not_tested",
    "call_required": "not_tested",
    "observed_on": null,
    "evidence_url": null
   }
  },
  "tested_on": "2026-11-17",
  "tested_by": "Our team; actor, account and scope are documented in the review.",
  "review_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html",
  "method": [
   "Development store (Shopify plan Basic): installed the app and ran guided setup of a free membership plan",
   "Read the review screen and the Shopify test charge screen, approved the test charge without a card",
   "Opened the uninstall dialog and uninstalled the app"
  ],
  "claims": [
   {
    "claim": "Each member counts toward your app plan's member total",
    "claim_source": "our test notes",
    "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
    "observed": "The setup step for a free plan says that each member counts toward the app plan member total, so free members are counted, and the plan is billed per member. No invoice was seen, so this is only the app text.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence": {
     "label": "Our test observations",
     "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
    },
    "plan": "Scale test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
    "comparability": "App wording on member counting versus the dossier question on free members; no invoice was seen.",
    "status": "confirmed",
    "buying_consequence": "Free members count toward the member total, so a free plan is not automatically free of cost once the first 10 are used.",
    "buyer_direction": "unfavourable",
    "claim_changed_on": null
   },
   {
    "claim": "Free for your first 10 member signups",
    "claim_source": "our test notes",
    "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
    "observed": "The review screen says Free for your first 10 member signups. The listing says First 10 members are free forever; the app does not use the word forever.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence": {
     "label": "Our test observations",
     "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
    },
    "plan": "Scale test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
    "comparability": "Listing wording on free members versus the banner on the review screen.",
    "status": "confirmed",
    "buying_consequence": "The first 10 members cost nothing according to the app, but the app does not promise that this lasts.",
    "buyer_direction": "neutral",
    "claim_changed_on": null
   },
   {
    "claim": "$0.13 per member, per month",
    "claim_source": "our test notes",
    "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
    "observed": "The review screen says Bold Memberships is always $0.13 per month/customer, with no transaction fee and no monthly base fee; the listing says $0.13 per member, per month.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence": {
     "label": "Our test observations",
     "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
    },
    "plan": "Scale test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
    "comparability": "Listing price versus the review screen banner on one development store.",
    "status": "confirmed",
    "buying_consequence": "The price of $0.13 per member per month is the same in the listing and in the app.",
    "buyer_direction": "neutral",
    "claim_changed_on": null
   },
   {
    "claim": "100% free for the first 30 days",
    "claim_source": "our test notes",
    "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
    "observed": "The review screen and the Shopify approval screen show no free period of 30 days; the button says Start free trial and the approval screen says only that you will be billed when you begin to use the app.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence": {
     "label": "Our test observations",
     "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
    },
    "plan": "Scale test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
    "comparability": "Listing wording on a free period versus a review screen and an approval screen that show no number of days.",
    "status": "not_testable",
    "buying_consequence": "The 30 free days of the listing could not be confirmed in the app.",
    "buyer_direction": "neutral",
    "claim_changed_on": null
   },
   {
    "claim": "No flat monthly base fees",
    "claim_source": "our test notes",
    "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
    "observed": "The review screen says no monthly base fee and no transaction fee; no base fee line appeared on the approval screen either.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence": {
     "label": "Our test observations",
     "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
    },
    "plan": "Scale test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
    "comparability": "Listing fee wording versus the review screen and the approval screen, without an invoice.",
    "status": "confirmed",
    "buying_consequence": "No base fee and no transaction fee were shown anywhere in the setup.",
    "buyer_direction": "favourable",
    "claim_changed_on": null
   },
   {
    "claim": "Free to install. Additional charges may apply.",
    "claim_source": "our test notes",
    "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
    "observed": "The app installed without a plan choice or a price question and a free membership plan could be set live before any charge step; the Shopify screen came only at Start free trial.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence": {
     "label": "Our test observations",
     "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
    },
    "plan": "Scale test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
    "comparability": "Listing install wording versus the install flow on one development store.",
    "status": "confirmed",
    "buying_consequence": "Installing and setting up a free plan costs nothing; charges are tied to members.",
    "buyer_direction": "favourable",
    "claim_changed_on": null
   },
   {
    "claim": "Reason for uninstalling",
    "claim_source": "our test notes",
    "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
    "observed": "There was no cancel button looked for in the app; cancelling means uninstalling from Settings, Apps. The dialog requires a reason, deletes data such as discounts, sends a request to the developer within 48 hours to delete personal customer information and shows no warning about running charges.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence": {
     "label": "Our test observations",
     "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
    },
    "plan": "Scale test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
    "comparability": "The uninstall dialog on a development store; no paid member existed and no bill was seen afterwards.",
    "status": "confirmed",
    "buying_consequence": "The only way out is to uninstall, which needs a reason and removes the plan and its discounts.",
    "buyer_direction": "neutral",
    "claim_changed_on": null
   },
   {
    "claim": "App spending limit",
    "claim_source": "our test notes",
    "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
    "observed": "The listing and the review screen name $0.13 per member per month, while the Shopify approval screen shows no price and only a usage spending limit of a maximum of $10.000,00 USD per 30 days; it was approved as a test charge and billed nothing.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence": {
     "label": "Our test observations",
     "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
    },
    "plan": "Scale test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
    "comparability": "Price banner versus an approval screen with a usage spending limit and no amount; no stored cost rule was compared.",
    "status": "not_testable",
    "buying_consequence": "The price per member could not be confirmed on the approval screen, which shows only a spending limit.",
    "buyer_direction": "neutral",
    "claim_changed_on": null
   }
  ],
  "exit_test": {
   "run_date": "2026-11-17",
   "what": "The app was installed on our Shopify development store, which Daan set up, and our AI assistant ran the test in Daan's browser. On 17 November 2026 the session tested Bold Memberships on a Shopify development store: the install, guided setup of a free membership plan with exclusive access and a discount, the review screen with the price, the Shopify test charge (approved without a card, billed 0 dollars) and the uninstall dialog, after which the app was uninstalled. The storefront was not seen. Install: the App Store listing (English, now called Bold Memberships & Loyalty) says Free to install. Additional charges may apply., with a rating of 4.4 from 89 reviews. Install was clicked at about 11:36 and the app opened at about 11:38 after the Install app dialog (customer data, staff and contributor data, view and edit store data). There was no plan choice and no price question at install. The welcome screen says Build a membership that brings customers back. and offers Launch with an expert (Book a call, Start a chat) or Build it yourself with Start guided setup. We did not use the call or the chat. Core action: guided setup in three steps. Step one, Free or paid: plan name Test Member (tag test_member), and we chose Free for all customers (Customers join automatically, at no cost). A checkbox offers to add the 6 existing customers now; the text says that if it is left off, existing customers join when they place an order or click Join Now, and that each member counts toward your app plan's member total. Step two, Rewards and benefits: we chose Exclusive access, with the product Bundle Product #1, and Discounts, 10 percent named Member 10 off on All orders. Step three, Finish initial setup: Open theme editor and Create plans page were skipped, so no theme was changed and no store page was created. The review screen Almost done! shows the plan Test Member, the enrollment Free (all customers) and the benefits Exclusive access and Discounts, and says that Bold Memberships is always $0.13 per month/customer, with no transaction fee, no monthly base fee, Free for your first 10 member signups, and Enterprise pricing for over 5,000 customers. After approval the app said You're all set! Your membership plan is live. with a Polish your plan list (1 of 4 done). Timing, approximate tester observations: about 11 minutes from opening the app at 11:38 to the live plan at about 11:49, in about 14 steps. The plan was seen only in the app: the theme embed was not switched on, so the storefront widget and the gated product were not seen. Listing: Scale at $0.13 per member per month, 100% free for the first 30 days, First 10 members are free forever, No flat monthly base fees and No transaction fees. The app agrees on the price, no base fee and no transaction fee; the review screen says free for your first 10 member signups without the word forever and shows no 30 days free. Checkout: the review screen has one button, Start free trial, which opened the Shopify Approve subscription screen for Scale: You will not be billed for this test charge., This app bills you for usage charges, an App spending limit of a maximum of $10.000,00 USD per 30 days, and Your next bill: You will be billed for this app when you begin to use it. The screen shows no price and an Add payment method row. No card was entered and we approved this test charge at about 11:48, which cost nothing. Members: the app text says each member counts toward your app plan's member total, including free members. This was read from the screen only and was not proven with an invoice. Cancelling: we did not look for a cancel button in the app. Cancelling means uninstalling from Settings, Apps. The dialog Uninstall BOLD Memberships? says you will no longer be able to use the app, that data managed by the app such as discounts will be deleted, and that a request goes to the app developer within 48 hours to delete personal customer information. A Reason for uninstalling is required (we chose Testing multiple apps) and feedback is optional. The dialog has no warning about running charges or a refund. Not tested: a paid plan with member payments through Stripe, the storefront widget and the gated product (theme embed off), the wallet card, loyalty points, store credit, Shopify POS, the chat or call and the free setup with the team. Clean up: the app was uninstalled at about 11:55 and is no longer in the list of installed apps; the plan Test Member went with it. No theme change was saved, no page or navigation link was made. Our own tabs were closed. No kit records were entered.",
   "first_import": null,
   "file_inspected": false,
   "reimport_tested": false,
   "awkward": "The review screen shows no free period of 30 days and does not say that the first 10 members are free forever, the approval screen shows no price, and the only way to cancel is to uninstall, which needs a reason.",
   "friction": {
    "export_route": "No export or reimport was performed; no file was downloaded or examined. The two categorised kit records were not entered; the objects tested were not kit records.",
    "format": "No downloaded bytes examined.",
    "reimport": "No reimport performed.",
    "cancellation": "No cancellation or downgrade performed."
   },
   "not_tested": [
    "Original store creation and identity check, which Daan did himself.",
    "A paid plan with member payments through Stripe.",
    "The storefront widget and the gated product, because the theme embed was off.",
    "The wallet card, loyalty points, store credit and Shopify POS.",
    "The chat, the call and the free setup with the team.",
    "Whether free members really appear on a bill, which was read only from the app text.",
    "Support, export and reimport.",
    "Session and source-reading date: 17 November 2026. Times are CET. The session started at about 11:38 CET. These are approximate tester observations, not benchmark timings. Midnight timestamps are required date anchors, not measured event times."
   ],
   "available_fields": [],
   "not_offered": [],
   "note": "A check of this export route with synthetic records, on the account and date stated. Re-importing the export was not tested. The exported file was not opened, so what it contains is unverified. Friction is described, not scored; this is not a verdict on the product.",
   "evidence_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html#exit-test"
  },
  "facts": {
   "trial_requires_card": {
    "value": "not_tested",
    "basis": "No explicit observation in the public evidence.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html#hands-on"
   },
   "trial_duration_confirmed": {
    "value": "not_tested",
    "basis": "No explicit observation in the public evidence.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html#hands-on"
   },
   "export_file_inspected": {
    "value": false,
    "basis": "The app was installed on our Shopify development store, which Daan set up, and our AI assistant ran the test in Daan's browser. On 17 November 2026 the session tested Bold Memberships on a Shopify development store: the install, guided setup of a free membership plan with exclusive access and a discount, the review screen with the price, the Shopify test charge (approved without a card, billed 0 dollars) and the uninstall dialog, after which the app was uninstalled. The storefront was not seen. Install: the App Store listing (English, now called Bold Memberships & Loyalty) says Free to install. Additional charges may apply., with a rating of 4.4 from 89 reviews. Install was clicked at about 11:36 and the app opened at about 11:38 after the Install app dialog (customer data, staff and contributor data, view and edit store data). There was no plan choice and no price question at install. The welcome screen says Build a membership that brings customers back. and offers Launch with an expert (Book a call, Start a chat) or Build it yourself with Start guided setup. We did not use the call or the chat. Core action: guided setup in three steps. Step one, Free or paid: plan name Test Member (tag test_member), and we chose Free for all customers (Customers join automatically, at no cost). A checkbox offers to add the 6 existing customers now; the text says that if it is left off, existing customers join when they place an order or click Join Now, and that each member counts toward your app plan's member total. Step two, Rewards and benefits: we chose Exclusive access, with the product Bundle Product #1, and Discounts, 10 percent named Member 10 off on All orders. Step three, Finish initial setup: Open theme editor and Create plans page were skipped, so no theme was changed and no store page was created. The review screen Almost done! shows the plan Test Member, the enrollment Free (all customers) and the benefits Exclusive access and Discounts, and says that Bold Memberships is always $0.13 per month/customer, with no transaction fee, no monthly base fee, Free for your first 10 member signups, and Enterprise pricing for over 5,000 customers. After approval the app said You're all set! Your membership plan is live. with a Polish your plan list (1 of 4 done). Timing, approximate tester observations: about 11 minutes from opening the app at 11:38 to the live plan at about 11:49, in about 14 steps. The plan was seen only in the app: the theme embed was not switched on, so the storefront widget and the gated product were not seen. Listing: Scale at $0.13 per member per month, 100% free for the first 30 days, First 10 members are free forever, No flat monthly base fees and No transaction fees. The app agrees on the price, no base fee and no transaction fee; the review screen says free for your first 10 member signups without the word forever and shows no 30 days free. Checkout: the review screen has one button, Start free trial, which opened the Shopify Approve subscription screen for Scale: You will not be billed for this test charge., This app bills you for usage charges, an App spending limit of a maximum of $10.000,00 USD per 30 days, and Your next bill: You will be billed for this app when you begin to use it. The screen shows no price and an Add payment method row. No card was entered and we approved this test charge at about 11:48, which cost nothing. Members: the app text says each member counts toward your app plan's member total, including free members. This was read from the screen only and was not proven with an invoice. Cancelling: we did not look for a cancel button in the app. Cancelling means uninstalling from Settings, Apps. The dialog Uninstall BOLD Memberships? says you will no longer be able to use the app, that data managed by the app such as discounts will be deleted, and that a request goes to the app developer within 48 hours to delete personal customer information. A Reason for uninstalling is required (we chose Testing multiple apps) and feedback is optional. The dialog has no warning about running charges or a refund. Not tested: a paid plan with member payments through Stripe, the storefront widget and the gated product (theme embed off), the wallet card, loyalty points, store credit, Shopify POS, the chat or call and the free setup with the team. Clean up: the app was uninstalled at about 11:55 and is no longer in the list of installed apps; the plan Test Member went with it. No theme change was saved, no page or navigation link was made. Our own tabs were closed. No kit records were entered. A check of this export route with synthetic records, on the account and date stated. Re-importing the export was not tested. The exported file was not opened, so what it contains is unverified. Friction is described, not scored; this is not a verdict on the product.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html#exit-test"
   },
   "export_reimport_tested": {
    "value": false,
    "basis": "The app was installed on our Shopify development store, which Daan set up, and our AI assistant ran the test in Daan's browser. On 17 November 2026 the session tested Bold Memberships on a Shopify development store: the install, guided setup of a free membership plan with exclusive access and a discount, the review screen with the price, the Shopify test charge (approved without a card, billed 0 dollars) and the uninstall dialog, after which the app was uninstalled. The storefront was not seen. Install: the App Store listing (English, now called Bold Memberships & Loyalty) says Free to install. Additional charges may apply., with a rating of 4.4 from 89 reviews. Install was clicked at about 11:36 and the app opened at about 11:38 after the Install app dialog (customer data, staff and contributor data, view and edit store data). There was no plan choice and no price question at install. The welcome screen says Build a membership that brings customers back. and offers Launch with an expert (Book a call, Start a chat) or Build it yourself with Start guided setup. We did not use the call or the chat. Core action: guided setup in three steps. Step one, Free or paid: plan name Test Member (tag test_member), and we chose Free for all customers (Customers join automatically, at no cost). A checkbox offers to add the 6 existing customers now; the text says that if it is left off, existing customers join when they place an order or click Join Now, and that each member counts toward your app plan's member total. Step two, Rewards and benefits: we chose Exclusive access, with the product Bundle Product #1, and Discounts, 10 percent named Member 10 off on All orders. Step three, Finish initial setup: Open theme editor and Create plans page were skipped, so no theme was changed and no store page was created. The review screen Almost done! shows the plan Test Member, the enrollment Free (all customers) and the benefits Exclusive access and Discounts, and says that Bold Memberships is always $0.13 per month/customer, with no transaction fee, no monthly base fee, Free for your first 10 member signups, and Enterprise pricing for over 5,000 customers. After approval the app said You're all set! Your membership plan is live. with a Polish your plan list (1 of 4 done). Timing, approximate tester observations: about 11 minutes from opening the app at 11:38 to the live plan at about 11:49, in about 14 steps. The plan was seen only in the app: the theme embed was not switched on, so the storefront widget and the gated product were not seen. Listing: Scale at $0.13 per member per month, 100% free for the first 30 days, First 10 members are free forever, No flat monthly base fees and No transaction fees. The app agrees on the price, no base fee and no transaction fee; the review screen says free for your first 10 member signups without the word forever and shows no 30 days free. Checkout: the review screen has one button, Start free trial, which opened the Shopify Approve subscription screen for Scale: You will not be billed for this test charge., This app bills you for usage charges, an App spending limit of a maximum of $10.000,00 USD per 30 days, and Your next bill: You will be billed for this app when you begin to use it. The screen shows no price and an Add payment method row. No card was entered and we approved this test charge at about 11:48, which cost nothing. Members: the app text says each member counts toward your app plan's member total, including free members. This was read from the screen only and was not proven with an invoice. Cancelling: we did not look for a cancel button in the app. Cancelling means uninstalling from Settings, Apps. The dialog Uninstall BOLD Memberships? says you will no longer be able to use the app, that data managed by the app such as discounts will be deleted, and that a request goes to the app developer within 48 hours to delete personal customer information. A Reason for uninstalling is required (we chose Testing multiple apps) and feedback is optional. The dialog has no warning about running charges or a refund. Not tested: a paid plan with member payments through Stripe, the storefront widget and the gated product (theme embed off), the wallet card, loyalty points, store credit, Shopify POS, the chat or call and the free setup with the team. Clean up: the app was uninstalled at about 11:55 and is no longer in the list of installed apps; the plan Test Member went with it. No theme change was saved, no page or navigation link was made. Our own tabs were closed. No kit records were entered. A check of this export route with synthetic records, on the account and date stated. Re-importing the export was not tested. The exported file was not opened, so what it contains is unverified. Friction is described, not scored; this is not a verdict on the product.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html#exit-test"
   },
   "export_direct_download": {
    "value": "not_tested",
    "basis": "No explicit observation in the public evidence.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
    "evidence_url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html#hands-on"
   },
   "marketing_emails_14d": {
    "value": "not_tested",
    "basis": "No complete unambiguous 14-day inbox observation available.",
    "observed_on": "2026-11-19",
    "evidence_url": null
   }
  }
 },
 "task_evidence": {
  "structured_checks": [],
  "sessions": [
   {
    "source": "session",
    "product_name": "Bold Memberships",
    "product_id": "bold-memberships",
    "run_date": "2026-11-17",
    "session_type": "hands_on",
    "what": "The app was installed on our Shopify development store, which Daan set up, and our AI assistant ran the test in Daan's browser. On 17 November 2026 the session tested Bold Memberships on a Shopify development store: the install, guided setup of a free membership plan with exclusive access and a discount, the review screen with the price, the Shopify test charge (approved without a card, billed 0 dollars) and the uninstall dialog, after which the app was uninstalled. The storefront was not seen. Install: the App Store listing (English, now called Bold Memberships & Loyalty) says Free to install. Additional charges may apply., with a rating of 4.4 from 89 reviews. Install was clicked at about 11:36 and the app opened at about 11:38 after the Install app dialog (customer data, staff and contributor data, view and edit store data). There was no plan choice and no price question at install. The welcome screen says Build a membership that brings customers back. and offers Launch with an expert (Book a call, Start a chat) or Build it yourself with Start guided setup. We did not use the call or the chat. Core action: guided setup in three steps. Step one, Free or paid: plan name Test Member (tag test_member), and we chose Free for all customers (Customers join automatically, at no cost). A checkbox offers to add the 6 existing customers now; the text says that if it is left off, existing customers join when they place an order or click Join Now, and that each member counts toward your app plan's member total. Step two, Rewards and benefits: we chose Exclusive access, with the product Bundle Product #1, and Discounts, 10 percent named Member 10 off on All orders. Step three, Finish initial setup: Open theme editor and Create plans page were skipped, so no theme was changed and no store page was created. The review screen Almost done! shows the plan Test Member, the enrollment Free (all customers) and the benefits Exclusive access and Discounts, and says that Bold Memberships is always $0.13 per month/customer, with no transaction fee, no monthly base fee, Free for your first 10 member signups, and Enterprise pricing for over 5,000 customers. After approval the app said You're all set! Your membership plan is live. with a Polish your plan list (1 of 4 done). Timing, approximate tester observations: about 11 minutes from opening the app at 11:38 to the live plan at about 11:49, in about 14 steps. The plan was seen only in the app: the theme embed was not switched on, so the storefront widget and the gated product were not seen. Listing: Scale at $0.13 per member per month, 100% free for the first 30 days, First 10 members are free forever, No flat monthly base fees and No transaction fees. The app agrees on the price, no base fee and no transaction fee; the review screen says free for your first 10 member signups without the word forever and shows no 30 days free. Checkout: the review screen has one button, Start free trial, which opened the Shopify Approve subscription screen for Scale: You will not be billed for this test charge., This app bills you for usage charges, an App spending limit of a maximum of $10.000,00 USD per 30 days, and Your next bill: You will be billed for this app when you begin to use it. The screen shows no price and an Add payment method row. No card was entered and we approved this test charge at about 11:48, which cost nothing. Members: the app text says each member counts toward your app plan's member total, including free members. This was read from the screen only and was not proven with an invoice. Cancelling: we did not look for a cancel button in the app. Cancelling means uninstalling from Settings, Apps. The dialog Uninstall BOLD Memberships? says you will no longer be able to use the app, that data managed by the app such as discounts will be deleted, and that a request goes to the app developer within 48 hours to delete personal customer information. A Reason for uninstalling is required (we chose Testing multiple apps) and feedback is optional. The dialog has no warning about running charges or a refund. Not tested: a paid plan with member payments through Stripe, the storefront widget and the gated product (theme embed off), the wallet card, loyalty points, store credit, Shopify POS, the chat or call and the free setup with the team. Clean up: the app was uninstalled at about 11:55 and is no longer in the list of installed apps; the plan Test Member went with it. No theme change was saved, no page or navigation link was made. Our own tabs were closed. No kit records were entered.",
    "findings": [
     "Text we checked: \"Each member counts toward your app plan's member total\". What we saw: The setup step for a free plan says that each member counts toward the app plan member total, so free members are counted, and the plan is billed per member. No invoice was seen, so this is only the app text.",
     "Text we checked: \"Free for your first 10 member signups\". What we saw: The review screen says Free for your first 10 member signups. The listing says First 10 members are free forever; the app does not use the word forever.",
     "Text we checked: \"$0.13 per member, per month\". What we saw: The review screen says Bold Memberships is always $0.13 per month/customer, with no transaction fee and no monthly base fee; the listing says $0.13 per member, per month.",
     "Text we checked: \"No flat monthly base fees\". What we saw: The review screen says no monthly base fee and no transaction fee; no base fee line appeared on the approval screen either.",
     "Text we checked: \"Free to install. Additional charges may apply\". What we saw: The app installed without a plan choice or a price question and a free membership plan could be set live before any charge step; the Shopify screen came only at Start free trial."
    ],
    "not_tested": [
     "Original store creation and identity check, which Daan did himself.",
     "A paid plan with member payments through Stripe.",
     "The storefront widget and the gated product, because the theme embed was off.",
     "The wallet card, loyalty points, store credit and Shopify POS.",
     "The chat, the call and the free setup with the team.",
     "Whether free members really appear on a bill, which was read only from the app text.",
     "Support, export and reimport.",
     "Session and source-reading date: 17 November 2026. Times are CET. The session started at about 11:38 CET. These are approximate tester observations, not benchmark timings. Midnight timestamps are required date anchors, not measured event times."
    ],
    "report": null,
    "disclosure": null,
    "evidence_status": null,
    "result": "reported",
    "note": "Findings as written up after the session; no pass/fail per task was scored.",
    "claim_checks": [
     {
      "claim": "Each member counts toward your app plan's member total",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "The setup step for a free plan says that each member counts toward the app plan member total, so free members are counted, and the plan is billed per member. No invoice was seen, so this is only the app text.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Scale test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
      "comparability": "App wording on member counting versus the dossier question on free members; no invoice was seen.",
      "status": "confirmed",
      "buying_consequence": "Free members count toward the member total, so a free plan is not automatically free of cost once the first 10 are used.",
      "buyer_direction": "unfavourable",
      "claim_changed_on": null
     },
     {
      "claim": "Free for your first 10 member signups",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "The review screen says Free for your first 10 member signups. The listing says First 10 members are free forever; the app does not use the word forever.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Scale test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
      "comparability": "Listing wording on free members versus the banner on the review screen.",
      "status": "confirmed",
      "buying_consequence": "The first 10 members cost nothing according to the app, but the app does not promise that this lasts.",
      "buyer_direction": "neutral",
      "claim_changed_on": null
     },
     {
      "claim": "$0.13 per member, per month",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "The review screen says Bold Memberships is always $0.13 per month/customer, with no transaction fee and no monthly base fee; the listing says $0.13 per member, per month.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Scale test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
      "comparability": "Listing price versus the review screen banner on one development store.",
      "status": "confirmed",
      "buying_consequence": "The price of $0.13 per member per month is the same in the listing and in the app.",
      "buyer_direction": "neutral",
      "claim_changed_on": null
     },
     {
      "claim": "100% free for the first 30 days",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "The review screen and the Shopify approval screen show no free period of 30 days; the button says Start free trial and the approval screen says only that you will be billed when you begin to use the app.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Scale test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
      "comparability": "Listing wording on a free period versus a review screen and an approval screen that show no number of days.",
      "status": "not_testable",
      "buying_consequence": "The 30 free days of the listing could not be confirmed in the app.",
      "buyer_direction": "neutral",
      "claim_changed_on": null
     },
     {
      "claim": "No flat monthly base fees",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "The review screen says no monthly base fee and no transaction fee; no base fee line appeared on the approval screen either.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Scale test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
      "comparability": "Listing fee wording versus the review screen and the approval screen, without an invoice.",
      "status": "confirmed",
      "buying_consequence": "No base fee and no transaction fee were shown anywhere in the setup.",
      "buyer_direction": "favourable",
      "claim_changed_on": null
     },
     {
      "claim": "Free to install. Additional charges may apply.",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "The app installed without a plan choice or a price question and a free membership plan could be set live before any charge step; the Shopify screen came only at Start free trial.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Scale test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
      "comparability": "Listing install wording versus the install flow on one development store.",
      "status": "confirmed",
      "buying_consequence": "Installing and setting up a free plan costs nothing; charges are tied to members.",
      "buyer_direction": "favourable",
      "claim_changed_on": null
     },
     {
      "claim": "Reason for uninstalling",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "There was no cancel button looked for in the app; cancelling means uninstalling from Settings, Apps. The dialog requires a reason, deletes data such as discounts, sends a request to the developer within 48 hours to delete personal customer information and shows no warning about running charges.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Scale test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
      "comparability": "The uninstall dialog on a development store; no paid member existed and no bill was seen afterwards.",
      "status": "confirmed",
      "buying_consequence": "The only way out is to uninstall, which needs a reason and removes the plan and its discounts.",
      "buyer_direction": "neutral",
      "claim_changed_on": null
     },
     {
      "claim": "App spending limit",
      "claim_source": "our test notes",
      "claim_read_on": "2026-11-17",
      "observed": "The listing and the review screen name $0.13 per member per month, while the Shopify approval screen shows no price and only a usage spending limit of a maximum of $10.000,00 USD per 30 days; it was approved as a test charge and billed nothing.",
      "observed_on": "2026-11-17",
      "evidence": {
       "label": "Our test observations",
       "url": "https://marketingandsalessoftware.com/bold-memberships-review.html#claim-vs-measured"
      },
      "plan": "Scale test charge on a development store, billed 0 dollars",
      "comparability": "Price banner versus an approval screen with a usage spending limit and no amount; no stored cost rule was compared.",
      "status": "not_testable",
      "buying_consequence": "The price per member could not be confirmed on the approval screen, which shows only a spending limit.",
      "buyer_direction": "neutral",
      "claim_changed_on": null
     }
    ],
    "claim_checks_note": "A vendor claim (quoted, with source and read date) set against what we observed in this session on the plan stated. status is confirmed, contradicted, not_comparable, not_testable or out_of_date; it is not a score of the product.",
    "exit_test": {
     "run_date": "2026-11-17",
     "what": "The app was installed on our Shopify development store, which Daan set up, and our AI assistant ran the test in Daan's browser. On 17 November 2026 the session tested Bold Memberships on a Shopify development store: the install, guided setup of a free membership plan with exclusive access and a discount, the review screen with the price, the Shopify test charge (approved without a card, billed 0 dollars) and the uninstall dialog, after which the app was uninstalled. The storefront was not seen. Install: the App Store listing (English, now called Bold Memberships & Loyalty) says Free to install. Additional charges may apply., with a rating of 4.4 from 89 reviews. Install was clicked at about 11:36 and the app opened at about 11:38 after the Install app dialog (customer data, staff and contributor data, view and edit store data). There was no plan choice and no price question at install. The welcome screen says Build a membership that brings customers back. and offers Launch with an expert (Book a call, Start a chat) or Build it yourself with Start guided setup. We did not use the call or the chat. Core action: guided setup in three steps. Step one, Free or paid: plan name Test Member (tag test_member), and we chose Free for all customers (Customers join automatically, at no cost). A checkbox offers to add the 6 existing customers now; the text says that if it is left off, existing customers join when they place an order or click Join Now, and that each member counts toward your app plan's member total. Step two, Rewards and benefits: we chose Exclusive access, with the product Bundle Product #1, and Discounts, 10 percent named Member 10 off on All orders. Step three, Finish initial setup: Open theme editor and Create plans page were skipped, so no theme was changed and no store page was created. The review screen Almost done! shows the plan Test Member, the enrollment Free (all customers) and the benefits Exclusive access and Discounts, and says that Bold Memberships is always $0.13 per month/customer, with no transaction fee, no monthly base fee, Free for your first 10 member signups, and Enterprise pricing for over 5,000 customers. After approval the app said You're all set! Your membership plan is live. with a Polish your plan list (1 of 4 done). Timing, approximate tester observations: about 11 minutes from opening the app at 11:38 to the live plan at about 11:49, in about 14 steps. The plan was seen only in the app: the theme embed was not switched on, so the storefront widget and the gated product were not seen. Listing: Scale at $0.13 per member per month, 100% free for the first 30 days, First 10 members are free forever, No flat monthly base fees and No transaction fees. The app agrees on the price, no base fee and no transaction fee; the review screen says free for your first 10 member signups without the word forever and shows no 30 days free. Checkout: the review screen has one button, Start free trial, which opened the Shopify Approve subscription screen for Scale: You will not be billed for this test charge., This app bills you for usage charges, an App spending limit of a maximum of $10.000,00 USD per 30 days, and Your next bill: You will be billed for this app when you begin to use it. The screen shows no price and an Add payment method row. No card was entered and we approved this test charge at about 11:48, which cost nothing. Members: the app text says each member counts toward your app plan's member total, including free members. This was read from the screen only and was not proven with an invoice. Cancelling: we did not look for a cancel button in the app. Cancelling means uninstalling from Settings, Apps. The dialog Uninstall BOLD Memberships? says you will no longer be able to use the app, that data managed by the app such as discounts will be deleted, and that a request goes to the app developer within 48 hours to delete personal customer information. A Reason for uninstalling is required (we chose Testing multiple apps) and feedback is optional. The dialog has no warning about running charges or a refund. Not tested: a paid plan with member payments through Stripe, the storefront widget and the gated product (theme embed off), the wallet card, loyalty points, store credit, Shopify POS, the chat or call and the free setup with the team. Clean up: the app was uninstalled at about 11:55 and is no longer in the list of installed apps; the plan Test Member went with it. No theme change was saved, no page or navigation link was made. Our own tabs were closed. No kit records were entered.",
     "first_import": null,
     "file_inspected": false,
     "reimport_tested": false,
     "awkward": "The review screen shows no free period of 30 days and does not say that the first 10 members are free forever, the approval screen shows no price, and the only way to cancel is to uninstall, which needs a reason.",
     "friction": {
      "export_route": "No export or reimport was performed; no file was downloaded or examined. The two categorised kit records were not entered; the objects tested were not kit records.",
      "format": "No downloaded bytes examined.",
      "reimport": "No reimport performed.",
      "cancellation": "No cancellation or downgrade performed."
     },
     "not_tested": [
      "Original store creation and identity check, which Daan did himself.",
      "A paid plan with member payments through Stripe.",
      "The storefront widget and the gated product, because the theme embed was off.",
      "The wallet card, loyalty points, store credit and Shopify POS.",
      "The chat, the call and the free setup with the team.",
      "Whether free members really appear on a bill, which was read only from the app text.",
      "Support, export and reimport.",
      "Session and source-reading date: 17 November 2026. Times are CET. The session started at about 11:38 CET. These are approximate tester observations, not benchmark timings. Midnight timestamps are required date anchors, not measured event times."
     ],
     "available_fields": [],
     "not_offered": [],
     "note": "A check of this export route with synthetic records, on the account and date stated. Re-importing the export was not tested. The exported file was not opened, so what it contains is unverified. Friction is described, not scored; this is not a verdict on the product."
    },
    "in_catalog": true
   }
  ]
 },
 "open_questions": [
  {
   "question_id": "bold-memberships:cancellation_terms",
   "key": "cancellation_terms",
   "question": "Can a customer cancel at any time, and what happens to an annual plan that is cancelled mid-term?",
   "status": "open"
  },
  {
   "question_id": "bold-memberships:data_export",
   "key": "data_export",
   "question": "Which data can a customer export, in which formats, on which plans?",
   "status": "open"
  },
  {
   "question_id": "bold-memberships:data_location",
   "key": "data_location",
   "question": "Where is customer data stored, and can a customer choose the region?",
   "status": "open"
  },
  {
   "question_id": "bold-memberships:minimum_seats",
   "key": "minimum_seats",
   "question": "Is there a minimum number of seats or users on any plan?",
   "status": "open"
  }
 ],
 "vendor_answers": [],
 "agent_channels": {
  "vendor_mcp": null,
  "agent_checkout": {
   "status": "not_checked",
   "detail": "We could not read the vendor's pages as plain HTML.",
   "checked_at": "2026-10-07",
   "method": "homepage, /pricing and the pricing page we cite, read as plain HTML (no JavaScript) and searched for explicit support of purchases by AI agents: Agentic Commerce Protocol, Instant Checkout, Agent Payments Protocol, buy in ChatGPT, agentic checkout"
  }
 }
}
